5 ms·
It takes two to tango. Shortage takes both low supply and high demand. The tech industry did create this problem by suddenly attracting a ton of talent to the r
by closeparen 10y ago
It takes two to tango. Shortage takes both low supply and high demand. The tech industry did create this problem by suddenly attracting a ton of talent to the region. The municipalities passed on their opportunity to avert the housing crisis by embracing the change and their new role as Manhattan's tech counterpart, but it also could have been avoided had we chosen some other place, or a more remote/distributed mode.
- tmh79 10y agoIt is the responsibility of industry to attract people to a region, so these people can fill the jobs that industry requires; in most other places, this is celebrated. It is the responsibility of government to ensure a well functioning society. It appears clear to me that the government is failing its responsibility. The governments could have averted this crises by not zoning their municipalities for 3x, 4x, 5x more jobs than housing units within their borders. Its not like many of these offices have existed forever, they willingly allowed the creating of new offices, with out the requisite housing to support. (See, New Apple Spaceship HQ, Facebook campus, and expansion in Menlo Park, Google's constant expansion, the numerous new office parks that have sprung up in every city on the peninsula in the last 10 years). Much of this is jobs/housing imbalance is a result from prop 13, which disincentivized housing construction by making the development of commercial property more net tax advantageous (taxes in minus services provided) when compared with housing.
- Hondor 10y agoDemocratic governments exist to serve the people who vote for them. I'd say they have succeeded in increasing property values for property owners who voted for them. Every single house in SF is owned by someone, and that someone benefits from this situation persisting, so there are quite a lot of winners.
- narag 10y agoDemocratic governments exist to serve the people who vote for them. Democratic governments should serve everybody, not only the people that voted for them. Of course they'll have some obvious preferences, but neglecting or even crushing a sizeable group of people because they're not their voters is not what democracy is meant to be. It's not even wise.
- closeparen 10y ago>The governments could have averted this crises by not zoning their municipalities for 3x, 4x, 5x more jobs than housing units within their borders. Each municipal government is correctly pursuing a local optimum by doing this. The life of an existing homeowner gets no worse for the presence of a tech company office in their municipality, and the tax revenue from the company can be used to fund better services and/or lower taxes for locals. Night-time populations, on the other hand, require water and sewer and education and policing, more wear on the roads or staggeringly expensive public transit buildouts, etc. Each city is pursuing the best interests of its home-owning electorate in signing up for the tax revenue without the responsibility. Ignoring property values and aesthetics, the first municipality to liberalize housing construction will get to pay all the scaling costs that the whole region should have shared.
- Tempest1981 10y agoBut successful companies have a strong influence on government -- keeping taxes low, else threatening the leave. As Bernie said: govt doesn't regulate business - it's the other way around. Businesses dictate what they want. Blame shareholders, and boards of directors? But I don't expect them to change -- they're having a great run.
- jimmywanger 10y ago> The tech industry did create this problem by suddenly attracting a ton of talent to the region. Suddenly? This has been going on for close to 30 years. We haven't "created" a problem. > had we chosen some other place It's not as though some gigantic hive mind suddenly just put their finger down on a map and decided where to locate a tech center. And any other place they picked would be going through the same issues right now.
- closeparen 10y agoThis looks pretty sudden to me: [0] [0] https://medium.com/@mccannatron/1979-to-2015-average-rent-in-san-francisco-33aaea22de0e#.z2sjmzcpm https://medium.com/@mccannatron/1979-to-2015-average-rent-in...
- tmh79 10y agoThe first graph is misleading, as it shows a spike, but what really matters is the YoY % change. As you can see in the second graph, the YoY % change relative to inflation has been above 0 since 1979. You can't have an asset (or cost, if this is rents) that is vital to life increase in price above inflation literally every year since 1979 and expect that the price will be reasonable in 2016.
- mdorazio 10y agoI have to disagree with you. Can you provide an example of any desirable major metro in the US (besides Detroit) where housing prices have actually gone down YoY in the last 30 years? Even cities like Atalanta and Dallas with virtually unlimited space and new housing-friendly construction policies have had consistently increasing median rents for a long time. Small percentage increases in rent/house prices are normal due to a number of factors. It's the large spikes outstripping the normal increases that make things get crazy. And you can see this empirically in SF as well. If you were in the city post dotcom crash, housing was easy to find and also reasonably priced for CA. It's only been in the last 10 years or so that everything got out of control due to the new tech boom.