6 ms·
What is wrong with the Pilot Wave Theory intepretation? I'm ok with FTL information transfer, and so Bell's inequalities are satisfied. And anyway the other in
by EGreg 10y ago
What is wrong with the Pilot Wave Theory intepretation? I'm ok with FTL information transfer, and so Bell's inequalities are satisfied.
And anyway the other interpretations DO NOT rule out FTL information transfer. For example if one entangled electron flies into a black hole then we would be able to know its spin by measuring the other one even if light from it won't reach us.
Also there is this:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner's_friend https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner's_friend
- baytrailcat 10y ago>I'm ok with FTL information transfer Which will lead to the conclusion that Special Relativity (which was extensively validated) is either wrong or incomplete. I have seen a revival of Pilot-wave theory here on HN, but the real conclusion (a real particle pushed around by the enigmatic pilot wave or quantum potential or whatever) is as bizarre or as satisfying as saying particle is in a superposition. Also, I haven't seen anyone satisfyingly explain, in a classical-deterministic sense, the Delayed Choice Quantum Eraser Experiment (also, see the the Wheeler Thought Experiment)
- goatlover 10y agoThere is the silicone oil droplet phenomena which is a classical version of the pilot wave, and it does reproduce some quantum behavior, including the double slit. That a pilot wave has been discovered (granted at macro scale) does make one reconsider. https://youtu.be/WIyTZDHuarQ https://youtu.be/WIyTZDHuarQ
- krastanov 10y agoIt does not, really. The macroscopic realisation is not particularly surprising (although it is quite awesome and original). If you put a ball floating on top of a wave you will observe the predictions from a mathematical model of that system, which is exactly what the pilot wave theory is, and there is nothing surprising here. Moreover, the macroscopic model simulates something which by definition is an unobservable construction in the quantum model. It does not simulate any inherently quantum behavior (classical waves is a thing we already knew exists).
- lisivka 10y agoNobody tells that walkers are simulate all quantum behavior and doing that correctly. However, they helps to understand some of quantum puzzles. For example, droplets have spin. Can you predict behavior of the classical droplet spin in compare to the puzzling quantum spin?
- krastanov 10y agoBut you can do the same with classical setups that mimic some effects from the typical quantum mechanical formulations. Those classical experiments are indeed amusing and interesting, but they do not illuminate the "quantum puzzles", no matter whether they are modeled after pilot wave theory or after quantum mechanics. And very importantly, those amusing demonstrations do not scale! Sure, you can mimic with classical contraptions the pilot wave (or the wave function) of a single particle, but the nice intuitive demonstrations fail when you try to scale it up to more particles (or anything that would be exhibiting the interesting, nontrivial quantum behavior).
- lisivka 10y agoSo, your prediction for walker droplet spin is that walkers, in kind of Stern and Gerlach experiment, will behave like classical magnets, not like quantum particles, right?
- krastanov 10y agoNo, they would behave like a ball floating on top of a wave and given that there are waves involved there will also be interference patterns. There is nothing quantum here. Sure, in one particular way it looks like a quantum particle (to the extent of a cargo cult), but in all the important ways it does not (entanglement, computational power, generalisation to multiple particles).
- lisivka 10y agoI asking about outcome of Stern and Gerlach experiment. It's binary thing. Make public prediction, please.
- kkylin 10y agoAs far as I know there is no analog of entanglement in these experiments. If someone has heard or read something in that regard, I'd be interested in a reference!
- lisivka 10y agoNobody even tried to entangle two walkers. AFAIK, uncharged non-magnetic particle without any inclusions (e.g. bubbles) has spin and phase of vibration only. How to entangle them? Moreover, spin is 3d, walker is 2d, phase is 1d, while our Universe is 3d. It's like studying of 2d/1d projection of 3d world.
- lisivka 10y agoDid you saw double slit experiment reproduction in 2D macro?: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsaUX48t0w8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsaUX48t0w8 Observer breaks interference pattern.
- naasking 10y ago> Which will lead to the conclusion that Special Relativity (which was extensively validated) is either wrong or incomplete. Not necessarily. The simplest relativistic pilot wave theory requires only a preferred foliation of spacetime. This is seemingly unappealing to most physicists, but recent work has shown that the wave function itself contains just such a structure, so the needed foliation is present in every interpretation of QM.
- posterboy 10y agoWouldn't the entanglement just break? The preassure would rip the electron apart to begin with. I'm not sure if that erases entanglement already or if the quarks needed to be annihilated. Either way, are the known laws of physics applicable inside a black hole at all? I don't think so.
- krastanov 10y agoThe entanglement does not break. The entire black hole becomes entangled with the electron left outside (which is less exciting than it sounds). Sure, plenty of thing break if we start talking about unknowns, like the black hole evaporation for instance, but today's physics has a pretty good idea what happens if we just drop one of the electrons in the black hole and measure the other one. We just learn the spin of both of them at the same time, but we can not choose the value (it is random) hence there is no communication and no "weird peeking into the black hole".
- EGreg 10y agoThen how is it different than just splitting a coin, throwing the other half far away and then looking whether you have heads or tails? There is never any spooky action at a distance.
- krastanov 10y agoThis is a pretty great question with a fairly subtle answer. It is not much more than just flipping a coin, indeed! See section "4. Relativistic Causality" of http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec11.html http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec11.html for the best explanation I know of. This entire book "Quantum Computing Since Democritus" is absolutely great if you want to understand these topics. See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem TLDR: Think of it this way: We've got two players, Alice and Bob, and they're playing the following game. Alice flips a fair coin; then, based on the result, she can either raise her hand or not. Bob flips another fair coin; then, based on the result, he can either raise his hand or not. What both players want is that exactly one of them should raise their hand, if and only if both coins landed heads. If that condition is satisfied then they win the game; if it isn't then they lose. They can win 75% of the time if they just never raise their hands. Using a shared entangle state they can "cheat" and win 85.3% of the time by using a specific protocol, because they rely on some new form of correlation. But they still can not use this correlation to send messages (see the no communication theorem). Naively (this naive intuition does break!), you can imagine them having two slightly correlated coins - sure, after Alice flips hers she knows Bob's result, but she did not decide the result of her coin so she can not use it to send information to Bob.
- kkylin 10y agoWhat I personally do not like about pilot wave theory is that in the many body versions of the theory that I've seen, you still need a wave function that depends on the positions of all the particles. That is, the "pilot wave", unlike physical fields like electric or magnetic fields, is not a function of location in spacetime, nor is it attached to a particle, but to all particles. This means in a certain sense the amount of information in a given space grows exponentially with the number of particles. To me this has always been one of the mysteries of QM, and in pilot wave theory it is as much of a mystery. (The main thing that pilot wave theory clarifies for me is wave function collapse.)
- krastanov 10y agoThere is no information transfer in your black hole example. Entanglement can not be used for FTL communication no matter the interpretation you choose. As for why pilot wave theory is not popular: it generalises poorly. Sure, you can build a multi-particle theory or even field theory on top of it, but they are clumsy to work with and after their initial study they did not show any promising way forward that was not available to the typical approach to quantum mechanics. Edit: Wiki article about why entanglement does not provide FTL communication even if naively it looks like it should be possible https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem
- thisrod 10y agoDo you understand the arguments that the ability to send a signal faster than light allows you to send that signal backwards in time? I've never met anyone who who understood special relativity but was OK with that.
- ebcode 10y agoHow so? Why should faster-than-light travel imply a reversal of the arrow of time? Can you explain the reasoning?
- krastanov 10y agoThis wiki page [1] explains why whether two events happen at the same time depends on your reference frame. If you can send signals faster than light then you can send a signal to an even far away and cancel that event. In another reference frame the sending of the signal would have happened after the far-way event has already happened. Hence, due to the "relativity of simultaneity" FTL communication is equivalent to sending messages to the past. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity
- lisivka 10y agoBy sending a message in two opposite directions, we can achieve 2c speed of information transfer. How that is possible?
- krastanov 10y agoNo, we can not, but the reason might seem subtle. S sends the same information in opposite directions to A and B. So A learns what B learns, but A can not use that to tell something to B, that S did not already know. A can not influence B, rather it is S that influenced both A and B.
- gizmo686 10y agoThe idea behind relativity is that the speed of light is constant in all reference frames. [0]. In order for this to work, we "warp" spacetime depending on the velocity of the observer. More concretely, imagine Alice and Bob are moving away from each other at 50% the speed of light. They both observe event some event, X, occur and note the location in space-time. If Alice observes that X occurs in the location (t,x,y,z), then we can compute precisely where and when Bob observed the event occurring (t',x',y',z'). This conversion is known as the Lorentz Transformation [1], and can be derived mathematically from the assumption that the speed of light is constant regardless of reference frame. Where this gets weird is the case where Alice and Bob observe 2 events: X and Y. In this case, it is possible that they will disagree about which event happened first. Once you accept this, it should become clear why causality requires some speed limit. You can do the math based on the Lorentz Transform and confirm that this limit is the speed of light. Intuitively, this is a direct consequence of the fact that we defined the Lorentz Transform to make the speed of light constant. In case the need for a speed limit is not obvious, let as pretend that it does not exist. Suppose that, from Alice's perspective, X happened before Y. Further, suppose that Carol happened to be in a spaceship that passed by X at the instant it occurred, moving at a velocity that would take her by Y at the instant it occurred. [2] From the perspective of Bob, Carol would have traveled backwards, going from Y to X. We can make this situation even worse by considering Carol's perspective. Recall that we defined Carol as starting at X and traveling to Y. In the same way, we can define Dave as starting at Y and traveling to X (recall that, if we were Bob, we would be convinced that Y happened first, so with a fast enough ship, Dave and make it in time). In this situation, both Carol and Dave exist at Y, so Carol can give Dave a copy of her diary of the trip. However, after Dave makes the trip to X, he will meet Carol again, so he can give her a copy of her diary of the trip she is about to take. [0] This means that if I am on Earth, and you are in a space-ship moving at 99% the speed of light (from my perspective), and we both measure the speed of light, we will arrive at the same answer. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_transformation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_transformation [2] This is possible only because there is no limit to how fast Carol's Spaceship can travel.
- jayajay 10y agoPilot wave theory only postpones the question of "what is a wave function and how does it collapse?", it doesn't actually say anything new. I think Wigner's Friend is really no fundamentally different than Schrodinger's Cat.
- SidiousL 10y agoI'm not an expert in the Pilot Wave theory but my understanding is that it does not easily deal with many-particle systems. In the Pilot Wave theory the "wave" is a wave in space-time. In Quantum Mechanics, the wave is a wave in an abstract configuration space. In the case of multiple distinguishable particles this configuration space is just a product of the configuration spaces of each of the individual particles. When there are non-distingushable particles, one needs to cut down this space in various ways, depending on whether the particles are bosons and fermions. Needless to say, the Quantum Mechanics of multiple particle systems has received overwhelming experimental support. Actually, I have a question of my own regarding the Pilot Wave theory. Can a quantum computer exist in this theory? Is it just as or less powerful than a quantum/classical computer?
- wolfgke 10y ago> What is wrong with the Pilot Wave Theory intepretation? See > https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-more-physicists-subscribe-to-pilot-wave-theory https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-more-physicists-subscribe-to-... for a discussion where people of both sides answered. For an answer that is rather critical towards the Pilot Wave interpretation see > https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-more-physicists-subscribe-to-pilot-wave-theory/answer/Paul-Mainwood?srid=tCmX https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-more-physicists-subscribe-to-... Another skepticall answer is > https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-more-physicists-subscribe-to-pilot-wave-theory/answer/James-Swingland-1?srid=tCmX https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-more-physicists-subscribe-to-...