5 ms·
> I like <lots of serfdom economy stuff elided> The point isn't preventing YOU, the consumer, from doing this. The point is that most people as the supplier a
by bsder 10y ago
> I like <lots of serfdom economy stuff elided>
The point isn't preventing YOU, the consumer, from doing this.
The point is that most people as the supplier aren't doing Uber, AirBnB, etc because they like it. They're doing it because they don't have any other good alternatives.
Most of the people on the supply side of the serfdom economy are gaining very little benefit. This is a real problem.
- whack 10y ago> They're doing it because they don't have any other good alternatives. So champion proposals that would grow the economy, create more jobs, increase the median hourly wages, and/or improve the social safety net. I don't see how vilifying Uber or AirBNB is going to help accomplish any of the above. P.S. There is no way for you as an individual to be a supplier on the Seamless, but that still hasn't spared them the author's wrath. I don't think the author really has a clear idea of what he's complaining about.
- jacobush 10y agoCan't we rant and wail a bit about how increasingly broken shit looks? Why always champion a proposal to fix things? But thanks for the idea that vilifying Airbnb is not going to help anyone. I agree. They exist only because we let them fill that particular part of the biosphere. Maybe we shouldn't let them.
- closeparen 10y agoWho do you think is made better off by keeping that role in the biosphere vacant?
- jacobush 10y agoTo keep the analogy, some species we remove from the biosphere and replace with others. Airbnb and Uber etc look like the fast spread of an invasive species.
- ithinkinstereo 10y ago> I don't see how vilifying Uber or AirBNB is going to help accomplish any of the above. These companies are part of a greater force eroding the role and rights of labor. I think it's right to vilify the "sharing" company - especially with the type of "this is great for the world" propaganda that they spew out. If we accept these conditions as the norm, they will only continue to slide. We have laws and regulations for a reason. Bypassing said laws with billions in 1%, connected money, should rightfully be called out. Conveniences for the noble class aside, this is just part of a larger scheme to transfer capital from the poor/middle class into the pockets of the existing wealthy. It's a bit tone-deaf of you not to see the other side of the picture. Next time you're in an Uber, talk to the driver. You'd be surprised how many are doing this full-time because they can't find employment elsewhere... and even more when you discover how many actually understand the underlying economics of their "side hustle" (aka side-scammed).
- mkolodny 10y ago> You'd be surprised how many are doing this full-time because they can't find employment elsewhere... Isn't it a good thing that companies like Uber are creating jobs? Particularly for people who can't find employment elsewhere.
- wybiral 10y agoWhere did all of their jobs go? Also, aren't they experimenting with self driving vehicles so that those people don't have to work those kinds of jobs?
- mehwoot 10y agoIsn't it a good thing that companies like Uber are creating jobs? Are they, overall? Are they expanding the total amount of money paid out to workers in this industry? I'm not so sure that's the case.
- crazy1van 10y ago> If we accept these conditions as the norm What conditions are you referring to? The ability to work when you want for as long as you want? The ability to take an otherwise idle asset like your car or your house and make extra money with it? Anecdotally, I've taken dozens of Uber rides and never once heard the driver complain about Uber. I have, however, heard many drivers complain about proposed legislation that will harm Uber.
- olewhalehunter 10y agoAlso the author Matt Ruby is a circuit comedian and vlogger: professional complaining is his own personal form of brogramming: he has no actual solutions provided, he hasn't organized any communities, and the advertisement promotions on his startup comedy site "vooza" are indistinguishable from ones on the sites of some of the startups he's complaining about. Those who spend time consuming tripe like this or Silicon Valley, over some internet service, and then bitch about brogrammers are the problem. The efforts of greater people past are rotting under the asses of loud observers and you're no fucking Cesar Chavez.
- michaelchisari 10y agoIs it vilification, or is it a little dose of reality to counteract their marketing department?
- x0x0 10y agoRight, but to bring it back to the article, how is that a complaint against eg Seamless? All those restaurants in nyc delivered 10 years ago (well, Seamless was there then too) but you just called, dealt with the terrible English of whomever answered the phone at your various local ethnic food places, and played a bit of food bingo. The value of Seamless is discovery, ie not having to troll through the phone book, and an easier ability to order w/o language issues. And Uber is a taxi that comes. You just have to have experienced SF -- admittedly run by idiots playing city, badly -- pre Uber to understand why people love it. I mean, it's fair to criticize how Uber treats drivers, and I try to have cash to tip, but it's not exactly like taxi drivers were being treated particularly well before Uber. And they treated their customers like absolute shit.
- jjn2009 10y agothey have to do that because they live in an expensive area, hence living within your means, this is the part of the comment which you completely ignored. I make good money but I dont work an extra job just so I can live in sf, I just don't live there, its no ones right to live anywhere in particular and if you remove that constraint then "any other good alternatives" doesnt hold true but only for the very few people who literally cannot go somewhere reasonable to live for good reasons other than "it sucks". Everyone wants to make it sound like these people had a gun to their had and the only option was to be a wage slave to the uber type oppressors, this is completely lacking in perspective to the vast expanse of inexpensive areas there are in which unskilled labor can live comfortably.
- strken 10y ago>The point is that most people as the supplier aren't doing Uber, AirBnB, etc because they like it. They're doing it because they don't have any other good alternatives. How do you know this? The last five uber drivers I've had have been - a bloke on the way home from the gym - the owner of a small accountancy firm, also on the way home - an IT student from China who talked about PHP with me - a Korean migrant who really hated taxi companies and was saving up for a house - a CFO for a smallish company who was driving people around because he had to pick up his wife from the airport in a few hours They all seemed pretty okay with uber. Only one, the student, was driving as a primary source of income, and he was doing about 20 hours a week and making more than he would in any other job.
- tmuir 10y ago1. 5 day old account 2. Wide array of feel-good details to check lots of boxes 3. Completely anecdotal and therefore unverifiable 4. Facebook-level knowledge of people you likely spent 10 minutes with 5. Glowing review of Uber Isn't Fear Uncertainty and Doubt great?
- yummyfajitas 10y agoHere's another anecdote from a very old account. A boy from Bihar, moved to the big city, wanted to drive an auto rickshaw but the Marathis have all the licenses on lockdown. All Uber cares about is that he has a rating > 4.3 stars - ethnicity is irrelevant. (This is also why the racist political party is trying to get Uber shut down.)
- strken 10y ago2. When you ask a stranger about themselves, they put their best foot forward. People are pretty varied. 3. My experience has been that uber drivers in my city work part time for supplementary income. This is a verifiable assertion, but I don't have the means to carry out that verification. However, the assertion that I was responding to has no verification either. Plus, it probably varies from city to city and country to country 5. There are a lot of reasons why Uber is awful, from monopolistic bullying of governments, to not letting drivers set prices, to exposing drivers to market forces at an unprecedented level, but the drivers I've talked to have nearly all worked part time and seemed pretty happy to do so. I'm not in sales, I don't work for Uber, and that's all I'll say about the personal stuff.
- jlebar 10y ago> The point is that most people as the supplier aren't doing Uber, AirBnB, etc because they like it. They're doing it because they don't have any other good alternatives. Well, sure. Why is it the fault of Uber/AirBnB/Seamless/TaskRabbit/DishDash/Handy/whatever that they don't have better alternatives? And moreover, how exactly would these people's lives be better if they couldn't work for Uber etc.? Aren't they choosing to work for Uber etc. because it's better than the alternative (namely, not working for Uber etc.)? There are lots of fucked up things about our economic policy. I won't give my top ten because HN is trying not to be a place for political debates, but I'm sure you can name a few off the top of your head. We just had a long discussion about the importance of the ACA on HN -- taking that away hits the poor the hardest. We can go on. The governmental policies that perpetuate income inequality should be the target of your ire, not the fact that someone deigned to create yet another company that doesn't pay its employees "enough" money. Edited for formatting.
- knieveltech 10y agoI think the point that the author was trying to make was SV/startup/tech company bulshytt all touts technology* as equating to progress, and progress equalling some kind of unambiguous improvement to individual quality of life or society as a whole. This claim is open to critique given the exploitative nature of some/most/all sharing economy services, the frequently pointless and often time consuming nature of apps, etc. The idea here is if technology was in fact improving the economy, society, or the world the individuals who are stuck working 2nd and 3rd jobs would have other options available, especially in light of how many jobs/career tracks/industries software has eaten in the last 20 years. * poorly defined term in this context