3 ms·
It was intentional, they've thought about it. Yes, of course it is clearly less secure than Signal. It's an UI tradeoff given the reality that the vast majorit
by FabHK 10y ago
It was intentional, they've thought about it.
Yes, of course it is clearly less secure than Signal. It's an UI tradeoff given the reality that the vast majority of the billion+ WhatsApp users will not verify key fingerprints ("security number", I believe, in Signal speak) out of band.
Again, let me quote Moxie from the other thread:
"Given that reality, the most important thing is to design your product so that the server has no knowledge of who has verified keys or who has enabled a setting to see key change notifications. That way the server has no knowledge of who it can MITM without getting caught. I've been impressed with the level of care that WhatsApp has given to that requirement."
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13394900 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13394900
The point is, if you need the extra security, use Signal, Threema. But if you want to get good crypto in the hands of billions, make it simple and invisible. That's what they've aimed for, and achieved.