3 ms·
> Those who verify software have access to the source, open or not. That's not true. Black hats are essentially verifiers, and they generally do not have acce
by lisper 10y ago
> Those who verify software have access to the source, open or not.
That's not true. Black hats are essentially verifiers, and they generally do not have access to closed source.
- tptacek 10y agoHow do you look at the last 15 years worth of Microsoft Windows OS advisories and conclude that closed source has prevented hats of all colors from discovering vulnerabilities?
- lisper 10y agoWhy do you keep raising this straw man? It is obviously possible to reverse engineer object code and find vulnerabilities. But it is (equally obviously) easier to examine source code to find vulnerabilities.
- tptacek 10y agoThis slippery slope goes in both directions. Software is also easier to audit when it's built in higher-level languages, but we don't have ideological objections about verifiability to software written in C.
- lisper 10y agoI'm not sure I understand what you mean by that. Do you mean that people think that it doesn't matter what language code is written in as long as it is open source? I certainly don't believe that. It's pretty clear to me that C is a terrible language for writing secure code. (But coming up with something that is actually better than C is not so easy.)
- FabHK 10y agoAll agree that higher level (e.g. C) is easier to reason about than lower level (assembly). Now, you say that open source (e.g. C) is not only easier, but qualitatively different: open source good, closed source bad. tptacek points out: higher level (e.g. Haskell) is easier to reason about than lower level (e.g. C) - maybe even qualitatively. So, why are people only complaining about closed source, when they should (by analogous reasoning) be complaining about code written in C? Granted, it's possible to analyse, but it's obviously easier when it's written in Haskell!
- lisper 10y agoFor what it's worth, I complain about code written in C too.
- kazinator 10y agoHere might be something to look for among those advisories: how many of them were discovered in the source versus in the field. If the vendor is lazy about verifying code, it being closed is a big disadvantage. "We're not combing the code for bugs, and neither is anyone else; if it's not reported to us, it doesn't exist."
- kazinator 10y agoThey are verifiers who cannot, with straight faces, declare a body of code verified.
- lisper 10y agoI'll bet some of them can.