6 ms·
One thing that will let you in is if you are invested in from > investors with established records of successful investments The rich get richer. Established
by cma 10y ago
One thing that will let you in is if you are invested in from
> investors with established records of successful investments
The rich get richer. Established investors get cheap labor, while upstart competitive investors get buried behind an artificial government wall. I wonder if any established investment firms lobbied for that?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- icantdrive55 10y agoI think they want to prevent foreign rich parents from scamming the program? They want honest entrepreneurs? Not just the rich kids, with crafty parents? (Personally, I don't like these programs, except in extreme cases, like letting in accomplished scientists--for a limited time. And only from countries that reciprocate.)
- chulk90 10y agoDon't you think you're making too much assumption here? If a large firm lobbied to create an "artificial ... wall," they would write a pre-defined amount, such as "firms who have $100MM AUM," rather than making it vague. "Successful investments" can be validated with a reasonable argument, so it actually opens door for younger VCs.
- cma 10y agoOr maybe by making it vague they will get even more protection, especially if they have ins with the regulators who will interpret it. Seems more likely for established players than for upstarts. But maybe not. Just throwing it out there.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- orasis 10y agoSo your investment thesis is "cheaper is better."?
- lend000 10y agoSame with hedge funds. Government 'protects' the average investor by only letting qualified rich people invest in hedge funds (and get richer). I love how the government asserts that it knows what's best for me and protects me from myself. Such a free nation we live in.
- 8ytecoder 10y agoWhat bothers me more is the restriction on investing in IPOs.
- vostok 10y agoIsn't the restriction on investing in IPOs imposed by banks and not the government? You're just not going to get an allocation if you're not a "good customer".
- throwaway5752 10y agoYeah, that is 100% the result of the private financial system (investment banks). Remember when Google did the open dutch auction format and what a big deal that was for cutting them out?
- bsder 10y ago> Government 'protects' the average investor by only letting qualified rich people invest in hedge funds Having dealt with this situation recently, I'm a little more sympathetic to the government's position. Most investors are dumb. Really dumb. No, dumber than that. It's really easy for a con man to set up shop. It takes forever to get him shut down, and the scammed will fight you. Scammed investors will defend the scammer even when you present them with incontrovertible proof. You can stand in court and have a judge hand down rulings of the level of "worst case I have seen" and they will STILL defend him. Preventing these kinds of "investors" from even getting into the game is really the only way to keep it under control. Trump being elected was hardly a surprise to me given my recent experiences with dumb investors.
- _delirium 10y agoThis kind of rule (Canada was floating a similar one) is usually added in an attempt to keep visa-sellers out of the market, i.e. outfits who will agree to fake "invest" money in your fake "startup" in return for an under-the-table fee. By limiting the people who can count as investors to those who have a track record of actually investing in startups, the hope is that this kind of fraud will be at least less frequent, and easier to police.
- whack 10y agoThe EB5 program already exists which allows people to buy permanent residency. Anyone who wants to "buy a visa" can just do that with the full blessing of the government.
- _delirium 10y agoThat requires quite a bit more money, at least $500,000. Yeah, people who have that kind of money can already buy a visa. But a visa-reselling scheme here could be much cheaper, targeting people who want to buy a visa for, say, $30,000. The fraudulent investor would structure their investment so they don't actually part with the purported investment money (depending on what checks are done, there are various ways to either hang on to the money or round-trip it), and just charges a fee for agreeing to pretend to invest and temporarily fronting the required investment money.
- Finbarr 10y agoAll you get for your money is parole though -- not a visa. You couldn't work for other companies or stay indefinitely without getting another type of visa.
- oh_sigh 10y agoWithout it, you would have people just buying their way into 6+ years in the country.
- cma 10y agoHow about instead we use something similar to the existing framework for minimizing charity fraud?