95 ms·

As someone from mainland China and learned pinyin in grade 1 of primary school, which happened in early 90s, in Beijing, I use pinyin daily, for inputting Chine

As someone from mainland China and learned pinyin in grade 1 of primary school, which happened in early 90s, in Beijing, I use pinyin daily, for inputting Chinese into electronic devices. >All my Chinese teachers explained that young schoolchildren were taught basic pronunciation with bopomofo (which uses special characters, not latin letters), not pinyin. No, we use latin letters in mainland China, Taiwan uses special characters. The article is very accurate. Older generations like my parents have to learn latin lettered pinyin by themselves to use PCs and smartphones. And the pinyin form of my name and home address are on my passport.

nrjdhsbsid 10y ago
Can you explain the reasoning behind typing in pinyin to see the output in traditional characters? To a native English speaker this sounds silly and pointless. Is it something that's mostly tradition or is there advantage to typing this way?
- jhedwards 10y ago
  If you are asking why don't they type pinyin and leave it like that, then the reason is that Chinese, particularly mandarin, has a large number of homophones. Learning elementary mandarin sometimes felt like learning new meanings for the sounds "ma" "bu" and "shi" for two years. Despite having nearly the same pronunciation, all those syllables are distinct morphemes with unique characters to represent them, so characters are a clearer form of writing. If you are asking why they don't directly enter characters then the answer is that some people do, but it's not as convenient. To enter characters you draw it in a box with either a touch screen or a mouse and it's quite a bit slower, especially compared to the quality of autocomplete in pinyin entry systems.
  - nrjdhsbsid 10y ago
    Well explained. Does the similar pronunciation and many homophones cause any issues when spoken?
    - frivoal 10y ago
      A litlle. Intonation and non verbal cues help a bit with disambiguation. Also, while pinyin can have tone markers, they are a pain to type and are often omitted. It is not rare to see people who are having an oral conversation disambiguate words by drawing them with the index finger in the palm of their hand.
    - PeCaN 10y ago
      Not really, except that Chinese is a fantastic language for puns :D
    - jhedwards 10y ago
      Sometimes but not very often. The reason is that the rest of the words in the sentence together with the general situation is enough to make words unambiguous. This can be a challenge when learning because you have to map meanings onto both sounds and situations if that makes sense. It also means that Mandarin is great for making puns.
      - nrjdhsbsid 10y ago
        Does being situational make the language more efficient to speak? You don't need nearly as many words when the meaning is tied to context. I've always been curious about east Asian languages and culture since they're relatively isolated from Western influence and historic ties to the British empire
        bammyz 10y ago
        This might be the case for illiterate people, but these days it's mandatory for Mainland Chinese citizens to complete at least 9 years of education. Different words with the same written form usually have different pronunciations, and different words with the same pronunciation usually have different written forms. It's rare for a word to carry different meanings solely depending on context.
    - vorg 10y ago
      Spoken Mandarin is virtually always spoken with tones (except when sung, or when foreigners speak it), but when written virtually never has tones (e.g. signs). Only childrens books write the tone marks. So, along with various other intonation, there's a lot more information communicated during speech.
unityByFreedom 10y ago
> As someone from mainland China and learned pinyin in grade 1 of primary school, which happened in early 90s, in Beijing, I use pinyin daily, for inputting Chinese into electronic devices. Do you think learning Pinyin first threw off your early pronunciation of English? If people learned their languages in unique phonetic characters, would they be more likely to focus on learning the new sounds of other languages?

nrjdhsbsid 10y ago

Can you explain the reasoning behind typing in pinyin to see the output in traditional characters? To a native English speaker this sounds silly and pointless. Is it something that's mostly tradition or is there advantage to typing this way?

jhedwards 10y ago
If you are asking why don't they type pinyin and leave it like that, then the reason is that Chinese, particularly mandarin, has a large number of homophones. Learning elementary mandarin sometimes felt like learning new meanings for the sounds "ma" "bu" and "shi" for two years. Despite having nearly the same pronunciation, all those syllables are distinct morphemes with unique characters to represent them, so characters are a clearer form of writing. If you are asking why they don't directly enter characters then the answer is that some people do, but it's not as convenient. To enter characters you draw it in a box with either a touch screen or a mouse and it's quite a bit slower, especially compared to the quality of autocomplete in pinyin entry systems.
- nrjdhsbsid 10y ago
  Well explained. Does the similar pronunciation and many homophones cause any issues when spoken?
  - frivoal 10y ago
    A litlle. Intonation and non verbal cues help a bit with disambiguation. Also, while pinyin can have tone markers, they are a pain to type and are often omitted. It is not rare to see people who are having an oral conversation disambiguate words by drawing them with the index finger in the palm of their hand.
  - PeCaN 10y ago
    Not really, except that Chinese is a fantastic language for puns :D
  - jhedwards 10y ago
    Sometimes but not very often. The reason is that the rest of the words in the sentence together with the general situation is enough to make words unambiguous. This can be a challenge when learning because you have to map meanings onto both sounds and situations if that makes sense. It also means that Mandarin is great for making puns.
    - nrjdhsbsid 10y ago
      Does being situational make the language more efficient to speak? You don't need nearly as many words when the meaning is tied to context. I've always been curious about east Asian languages and culture since they're relatively isolated from Western influence and historic ties to the British empire
      - bammyz 10y ago
        This might be the case for illiterate people, but these days it's mandatory for Mainland Chinese citizens to complete at least 9 years of education. Different words with the same written form usually have different pronunciations, and different words with the same pronunciation usually have different written forms. It's rare for a word to carry different meanings solely depending on context.
  - vorg 10y ago
    Spoken Mandarin is virtually always spoken with tones (except when sung, or when foreigners speak it), but when written virtually never has tones (e.g. signs). Only childrens books write the tone marks. So, along with various other intonation, there's a lot more information communicated during speech.

unityByFreedom 10y ago

> As someone from mainland China and learned pinyin in grade 1 of primary school, which happened in early 90s, in Beijing, I use pinyin daily, for inputting Chinese into electronic devices. Do you think learning Pinyin first threw off your early pronunciation of English? If people learned their languages in unique phonetic characters, would they be more likely to focus on learning the new sounds of other languages?