6 ms·
> "We spent three years developing Pinyin. People made fun of > us, joking that it had taken us a long time to deal with just > 26 letters" I actually think i
by wodenokoto 10y ago
> "We spent three years developing Pinyin. People made fun of
> us, joking that it had taken us a long time to deal with just
> 26 letters"
I actually think it is quite fast. Grasping an entire languages phonology is a huge accomplishment and condensing it to its bare minimum is also impressive.
With that said, I must admit I don't know how pinyin relates to other phonetic systems such as the Bopomofo[0] or Wade-Giles[1] and for all I know it might just be the exact same system with different letters.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bopomofo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bopomofo
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wade–Giles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wade–Giles
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoPinyin is a little more compact (I.e. fewer Roman characters per Chinese characters) than Wades-Giles, so more efficient storage. That makes it easier to input chinese characters when using an English keyboard (or keypad on a mobile phone).
- emodendroket 10y agoIt's also arguably more aligned with the English pronunciation of the letters.
- FabHK 10y agoNot for initials (consonants): I find Wade-Giles ch'in more evocative than the Pinyin qin, and similarly hsüan vs xuan, and even tzŭ vs zi and tzʻŭ vs ci. Wade-Giles you basically have to learn not to ignore the apostrophe, Pinyin you have to learn most of the initials. Though the Wade-Giles jih vs Pinyin ri is a bit of a toss-up. For finals, I find Wade-Giles yü more consistent than Pinyin yu, but Wade-Giles to less descriptive than Pinyin duo. But then, it's shorter. So, yeah, "arguably" :-)
- uranusjr 10y agoNot a all. As a phonetic enthusiast I can assure you Pinyin is by far the worst representing Chinese sounds with English letters. It is made to represent Chinese phonetic, but its creators are seemingly completely ignorant toward basic phonetic rules, such as voicing and aspiration, and how words actually sound in English. As an example, b in English is called an unaspirated voiced consonant, which means you vibrate your vocal folds, but send only a little breath when you sound it. You can compare it with p, its aspirated voiceless counterpart, for which you do not vibrate the vocal folds (voiceless), but sends a strong breath through your month (aspirated). Chinese does not have most voiced consonants present in English, so Pinyin naively uses b (also d and some others) to represent voiceless aspirated consonants, which does not sound like a b, but more like p in “spade”. This results in most of the foreigners learning Chinese with Pinyin bringing English pronunciation when they speak, and makes them sound way too stiff and thus awkward. Wade-Giles, in comparison, is much more systematic, and does a much better job hinting speakers with European (especially Germanic language) background to sound more correctly. Bopomofo does not have this problem, as it basically invents a new set of scripts. Pinyin probably lets you pick up casual speaking Chinese most quickly, but beyond that, it’s a curse. [Edit]: Voice “folds” not cords, sorry. Also fixed some typos.
- achou 10y agoWhen I was taught Pinyin, the instructor explained that the phonetics were influenced by the Russian pronunciation of the roman alphabet. Not sure if this is true, or if it explains the issues you're describing. But it seemed plausible that China thought they were going to be closer to the USSR given the shared ideology in the 50's. In any case, as a person who has a decent pronunciation in Chinese but lacking the ability to fully read/write, Pinyin has been absolutely great for being able to type Chinese informally. I can communicate almost anything I can say, and that's truly wonderful. Part of that is the smart prediction software. But Pinyin has a big part in it too: it's not difficult at all to sound out a word and figure out how to spell it in Pinyin. That's the essential feature that Chinese characters lack, and Pinyin nails that essential quality as far as I can tell.
- uranusjr 10y agoI know very little Russian and can’t say for certain, but I think Russian is similar to English in these consonants. I should make it clear I don’t think Pinyin is a bad system, only that it does not map sounds to European languages well. And that is fine, as least for its original purpose. Contrary to common belief, Pinyin was not developed to better educate illiterate people (this does not even make sense if you think carefully), but as the next step after letter simplification (what we know as Simplified Chinese today) towards Chinese Romanisation. The goal was not to represent sounds of Chinese characters, but to outright replace them. The actual reason behind using (for example) b and p instead of p and p' is exactly this—they are optimising for ease to write, not sound accuracy. And in regard to making it easy for people not prolific with Chinese letters to read, be them foreigners or simply illiterate, a phonetic transcription system is indeed important. But although having a standard phonetic transcription is key to the jump in literacy in China, I would argue the same can be achieved with any decent system, and a few of them are already around by the time they started working on Pinyin. All in all, while Pinyin is good for its original purpose, it achieved its current status not because of academical reasons, but political ones. The Chinese Communists government had always have a habit ignoring existing systems and inventing their own. :p
- hetman 10y ago
- imjustsaying 10y ago>I actually think it is quite fast. Grasping an entire languages phonology is a huge accomplishment and condensing it to its bare minimum is also impressive. Absolutely. But I don't see how this statement could apply to pinyin. The work done on German's last spelling reform was impressive in this regard, but faulty pinyin was not.
- hgfdhjtyd 10y ago> but faulty pinyin was not. Is this a real opinion or just a political stand against PRC? How is pinyin faulty, specifically with respect to Mandarin Chinese? What Romanization system is better and how so?
- jason_slack 10y agoOP elaborates more about this below.
- wodenokoto 10y agoCare to expand on the faults of pinyin, and how they are more erroneous than say the German spelling reform? My experience with pinyin is that it is very robust, and I don't remember ever encountering pinyin that was ambiguous about how it is read (unlike written English or romanized Japanese). I have also never heard of standard Chinese syllables that are lacking a clear mapping onto pinyin. To me that is very impressive.
- emodendroket 10y agoWell of course it's not ambiguous like English because they had no historical baggage. But properly romanized Japanese is also never ambiguous.
- wodenokoto 10y ago"ene" can be えね and えんえ. > But properly romanized Japanese is also never ambiguous. What is "properly romanised Japanese" anyway? There are several modern systems in use [1] often mixed together (Even the government can't stick to the government mandated Kunrei-shiki). Some system represent ず and づ the same, some represent ティ and チー the same, some represent じ and ぢ the same. ō represents both O+O and O+U [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanization_of_Japanese#Modern_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanization_of_Japanese#Moder...
- footpath 10y agoYou're right about Bopomofo - both it and pinyin are based on the same pronunciations so there's actually a one-to-one correspondence between the two systems: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bopomofo#Pinyin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bopomofo#Pinyin
- FabHK 10y agoAs there are only about 400 syllables (ignoring tones) in standard Mandarin, it's a fairly quick exercise to make a complete one-to-one mapping :-)
- FabHK 10y agoOh, and here we go: All 400 syllables of standard Mandarin in Bopomofo/Zhuyin Fuhao, Wade-Giles, and Hanyu Pinyin: http://pinyin.info/romanization/wadegiles/basic.html http://pinyin.info/romanization/wadegiles/basic.html