3 ms·
> If, for sufficiently large n, your workforce does not look like your applicant pool, you have broken hiring practices. Well, one, to first order everyone in
by geofft 10y ago
> If, for sufficiently large n, your workforce does not look like your applicant pool, you have broken hiring practices.
Well, one, to first order everyone in the Valley has badly broken hiring practices.
Two, I don't think that's true. It's extremely common for, say, top universities' freshman classes to look nothing like their applicant pools, because their applicant pools are full of people who want to go to that university but genuinely wouldn't do well there. There are a lot of people who optimize for making good grades and a perfect SAT score and have nothing to characterize them otherwise, and I would expect there are way fewer of those people, by percentage, in the freshman classes. (And yes, the modern university application process came out of anti-Semitism and there are a lot of other indefensible things about it, but this effect, I think, is defensible.)
My personal hypothesis is that technical aptitude is pretty uncorrelated with demographics, but that due to (for lack of a better term) "the pipeline", certain demographics are more encouraged to stay with technical studies and apply to these roles than others. So you have demographic A, which consists of a large number of people of varying abilities, and demographic B, which is a smaller number of people who have done particularly well throughout the pipeline. A fair hiring process, that selects for people with high aptitude, would naturally reject many more people from group A (who weren't filtered out from the pipeline) than from group B.