6 ms·
You can demonstrate the presence of a vulnerability in closed source software but there's no way to demonstrate (or even provide evidence of) the absence of any
by lisper 10y ago
You can demonstrate the presence of a vulnerability in closed source software but there's no way to demonstrate (or even provide evidence of) the absence of any vulnerabilities.
- conradev 10y ago> no way to demonstrate (or even provide evidence of) the absence of any vulnerabilities I'd say that's hard for open source software to do as well.
- iwlbebnd 10y agoYes but it is trivial to backdoor closed source software. Introducing backdoors into open source source is also more difficult.
- lisper 10y agoSure, but so what? Hard != impossible. EDIT: WTF people? Why is every response to this comment being downvoted into oblivion? The sibling comment to this one (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13395657 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13395657) was killed in a matter of minutes despite being (IMHO) a perfectly reasonable and constructive response.
- tedunangst 10y agoBig Backdoor showing who's boss.
- tptacek 10y agoVotes aren't why that comment is dead --- note that it doesn't say "flagged". There is stuff that happens behind the scenes that [deads] users, especially new accounts; I think some of it might be voting ring related but not sure. (That comment is incorrect but I agree with you that it's constructive).
- tptacek 10y agoThat's identically true of open-source software. To put it in the theoretical terms you're probably most comfortable with: the programming language used to represent a computer program has nothing fundamentally to do with whether it can be verified. Obviously some languages are easier to verify programs in than others, but the gap between assembly and C in ordinary compiled programs is surprisingly small. Open vs. closed-source software is a concern orthogonal to verifiability. I know this is a tough thing for people to get their heads around since it challenges a major open source orthodoxy. I like open source too. But the people who ratified it were not experts in this field, and this particular benefit of open source is overstated.
- lisper 10y ago> the programming language used to represent a computer program has nothing fundamentally to do with whether it can be verified That's not true. The design of a language can make it easier to verify with respect to certain properties. For example, it is much easier to verify that a typical Python program does not dereference dangling pointers than a typical C program. It is true that open source does not help as much as some of its adherents like to think. But that doesn't mean that it doesn't help at all, and it is certainly not true that it cannot help substantially in principle even if it does not help much in current practice.
- tptacek 10y agoYou're using a word, "easier", that is keeping us off the same page. I agree that Haskell programs are easier in many senses to verify than PHP programs. But our field does formal methods verification of assembly programs, for instance by lifting them to an IR.
- lisper 10y agoThat's news to me. At least it's news that this is actually practical for any interesting cases (i.e. real crypto code). Do you have a reference?