3 ms·
In my experience, the programmers who are particularly able to negotiate aggressively and are conflict-seeking achieve the goal of getting their designs adopted
by geofft 10y ago
In my experience, the programmers who are particularly able to negotiate aggressively and are conflict-seeking achieve the goal of getting their designs adopted, which usually doesn't correlate with getting the best designs adopted. If you don't believe such a correlation exists, you get a more productive development team if you artificially avoid rewarding aggressive negotiation and self-advocacy. It's an important skill in other disciplines like sales (where the goal is to close the deal even if your company's product is unquestionably worse than the competitors' products), but not so much for engineering.
I also think this isn't so much "women aren't good at negotiating for themselves" as "women who negotiate for themselves aggressively and are conflict-seeking are penalized socially for non-womanlike-behavior, so they learn not to do so." There are legitimate criticisms to be made about implicitly buying into that social standard, but it seems like an easier change to just prioritize different things in compensation, if the goal is short-term fairness in compensation.
- hysterix 10y agoBecause somehow, someway women are never responsible for their own actions or behaviors. Thank you for illustrating that.
- ishields 10y agoNice slippery slope argument. If you're really so ignorant that you truly don't believe that society on a whole treats the same behavior differently depending on the sex of the person who's doing it then you really need to get outside.
- sheepmullet 10y agoDifferent negotiation techniques can vary in effectiveness based on gender (and a dozen other things). But you have to be in a super toxic workplace for less than optimal salary negotiations to cause wider social and team issues.
- sfrailsdev 10y agoSeems something of a straw man argument. Women have been saying that this is an issue for a long time, across a number of companies and industries, which points to a systemic issue, not an individual's responsibility.
- geofft 10y agoI'd say this demonstrates them being responsible: they're responsible enough to know that sexists like you are going to judge every single thing they do on the grounds of them being women instead of people, and they adjust their actions and behaviors accordingly. People can negotiate their salary aggressively. Women, evidently, can't.
- sheepmullet 10y ago> I also think this isn't so much "women aren't good at negotiating for themselves" as "women who negotiate for themselves aggressively and are conflict-seeking are penalized socially Are they? When I negotiate on pay it is with my manager and maybe someone from HR. How does this translate into social penalty? Do you have studies which show women who aggressively negotiate salary and change jobs at a similar frequency to men typically earn less than women who don't? Or have a worse social environment than men? I have a feeling you are extrapolating based on very limited studies.
- vmarsy 10y agoI don't think that's the parent point. One of the main ingredients of a successful negotiation is to be likeable. Men can be likeable and aggressive, leading to better results than a likable but non agressive man. Women on the other hand, have more difficulties being aggressive while remaining likeable. If they act agressively they get labeled as "bossy", a term that society rarely if not never use on men. Since remaining likable is more important than being aggressive for the long term, women have a harder time getting big raises. That's the social penalty I think the parent refers to.
- sheepmullet 10y agoLooking at a negotiation in isolation doesn't translate well to the real world. You don't need to be an aggressive person to be aggressive in salary negotiations. Being aggressive once or twice a year in salary negotiations with your manager is not going to land you a reputation as bossy. Edit: or are you saying the parent was suggesting that being aggressive in the workplace itself is the best/only way of getting ahead?
- user5994461 10y ago> One of the main ingredients of a successful negotiation is to be likeable. LOL. The only ingredient of a successful negotiation is leverage. You don't need and you shouldn't use anything else.