6 ms·
The ACA isn't supposed to help healthy and financially secure people like your lawyer friend. It is supposed to help sick and financially insecure people, by fo
by sanderjd 10y ago
The ACA isn't supposed to help healthy and financially secure people like your lawyer friend. It is supposed to help sick and financially insecure people, by forcing healthy people (who are in the majority) to subsidize the cost of their care (which is very expensive).
There's a moral question at the heart of this, the answer to which defines the solution space: do we, as a society, think it is important that all sick people receive care? If yes, there are a bunch of potential solutions, but they all involve healthy people subsidizing care for sick people. If no, there are, of course, a lot more options.
The thing that frustrates me about the current Republican approach is that they seem to want to answer "yes" to this question, while telling voters they will not have to subsidize care for the sick in any way.
Depending on your point of view, either the best feature, or the biggest failure, of the ACA was that it made this subsidy for the sick visible to anybody buying their own insurance, rather than hiding it behind taxes or complicated dynamics between governments, insurers, employers, and hospitals.
A little more succinctly: either we decide to let emergency rooms turn sick people away, or somebody will be paying for their care. There's no magical solution.
- Nrsolis 10y agoI think you've answered a question you'd like to answer instead of one you don't: WHY is healthcare in this country SO EXPENSIVE? The way to make care available is to drive down costs. We haven't done a single thing with the ACA to improve the affordability of care, we've just made the un-affordability a problem borne by the people who were already doing a good job of taking care of themselves. That's not a scalable solution. The ACA got us a lot of short-term benefit for a small group of people but set in motion a chain of events that will only drive UP costs while driving affordability down. And I'd like to argue that until we do something to improve the market dynamics of healthcare we are very likely to see this sort of thing continue to get worse until it's so unsustainable that it's like trying to legislate away the force of gravity. One thing I'd like to see in any future version of ACA reform is RIGOROUS price transparency by healthcare providers. It should be absolutely illegal for any healthcare provider to conceal, obfuscate, or otherwise obstruct the price discovery mechanism of the market. Even if you argue that consumers aren't the best people to decide what services are necessary or needed, they can rely on the advice of trusted advisors and popular understanding to shop for healthcare at providers known for offering good value. SO MUCH of health care isn't of the "emergent" kind but the kind that is for chronic issues that are the result of unhealthy living or plain bad genetic luck. We need to redouble our efforts to drive those costs of care down and start paying for results and not treatment. Paying for treatment encourages overconsumption. Paying for outcomes encourages optimizing for cures.
- krupan 10y agoWell said. Can we also work on the supply of medical care? We keep giving more and more people insurance which increases demand without doing anything to increase supply and then wonder why prices go up.
- tunesmith 10y agoYour second paragraph is not even close to true - if you do more research on the ACA you'll find that it does all kinds of things to try and improve the affordability of care, a lot of which has made real improvements. Incentives against fee-for-service, quality-of-care rules, medicare/medicaid rules, there's just a ton of that stuff in the ACA. The stuff in your last paragraph is directly addressed by many parts of the ACA. And, more can definitely be done, including price transparency etc. These things tend to be supported by Democrats and opposed by Republicans.
- Nrsolis 10y agoI think you should post some links to relevant sections of the ACA and show me where they take specific actions to drive down costs. I will tell you that I've seen scant evidence that it's working. A wishlist of initiatives isn't a plan for action that drives down costs. Allowing Medicare to NEGOTIATE prices for drugs is a plan to drive down costs. The insurance companies wanted to GROW the per-capita spend on healthcare. That benefited them. It's really really unclear if it benefited the public right now. Forcing people into a market they don't want to be in isn't reform. The way to solve this problem is to make being a part of the market ATTRACTIVE. IMHO we really missed an opportunity to affect behaviors. For one thing, Romneycare incentivized people to skip insurance until they needed it. That was a recipe for adverse selection. The way to help this is to provide incentives for people to get in WAY EARLY and pay for their OWN care long before they may need it while also providing a measurable benefit to those who get in early right away. People are capable of responding to incentives and I'm convinced that there exists a Nash equilibrium in healthcare that helps everybody win. Remember, the same people who gave you "the Internet is not a truck" are the same people you're expecting to solve healthcare affordability. Think about that.
- crusso 10y agoYou see the lack of honesty on both sides of the aisle. You're right in that Republicans don't just come out and admit that they believe that healthcare is not a right and that people should have to deal with their own health issues. Democrats don't just come out and admit that they want a wealth redistribution program that they can use to show voters how compassionate they are with other people's money. They're politicians. They just aren't honest and voters aren't perceptive or concerned enough to call them on it.
- majormajor 10y ago> Democrats don't just come out and admit that they want a wealth redistribution program that they can use to show voters how compassionate they are with other people's money. I want a wealth distribution program that means that thanks to a genetic condition I had no role in acquiring (if you're "doing a good job taking care of yourself" and never get cancer or some other nasty expensive disease, why don't you count your fucking blessings that you're healthy instead of bitching about having to subsidize others) means that I don't get a death sentence if I ever am sick enough to lose my job for long enough to lose coverage and get fucked over in the future on preexisting condition exclusions. Or fucked over due to lifetime benefit caps. And I want one that protects other people in similar situations too. So maybe not everyone's motivations are as cynical as you make them out to be.
- cderwin 10y agoYou might want a redistribution program, just like I don't want healthcare to be a right, but none of that changes that no politician will speak about their support for some healthcare policy in those terms. It would be electoral suicide if they're from a competitive district.
- ubernostrum 10y agoI want a wealth redistribution program as redress for past injustices. Current concentrations of wealth and property are the result of force and fraud, and I do not see how anyone should support preserving those distributions, let alone enshrining their preservation as a moral imperative.