4 ms·
> Well you could define what you mean by "not allowed to speak" Of course I meant she is not allowed to speak, quite literally. What else could it possibly me
by mistermann 10y ago
> Well you could define what you mean by "not allowed to speak"
Of course I meant she is not allowed to speak, quite literally. What else could it possibly mean after all, right?
So, in the spirit of this discussion, I will have to concede that what I was trying to articulate is absolutely 100% incorrect as it is based on a false premise, that she is literally not allowed to speak. Indeed, she is on camera numerous times speaking, which proves absolutely that I am wrong.
You win Don Hopkins. Congratulations.
- DonHopkins 10y agoSo why did you even come here and purposefully spread misinformation you knew wasn't true? What was your point? What was your goal? What you did was a systematic, pathological attempt to deceive, spread false conspiracy theories, discredit professional scientists, and deny global warming. Trying that hard so many times to articulate something you know is 100% incorrect is called "lying". You started out by defending Scott Adams and falsely accusing scientists of lying, but it turned out you were the one actually lying, you weren't accidentally mistaken, and you knew it all along. Don't pretend to be shocked that I'm unfairly calling you a liar, since I'll quote your own words back to you: "I believe many if not most scientists are at least partially lying to people, and by lying I don't mean they are accidentally mistaken, I mean that they know that some of what they are saying is speculative, but they pass it off as established fact." -misterman Go back over this thread and look at how many times and how vigorously you lied, did precisely what you'r falsely accusing other people of doing, and then feigned shock and mortal outrage that you were actually called on it, in a thread about "calling bullshit". What was the point to all your lies and false accusations, and are you going to continue to act this way in the future?
- tomhoward 10y agoYour comments have bordered on bullying or character assassination, rather than simply focusing on facts and data. It's this style of argumentation that makes your position seem less convincing. If it were simply about facts and data, you would be able to rely on facts and data to demonstrate your point and convince your opponent and other readers. Instead, you've used aggression and ridicule, and relied on multiple argumentative fallacies (most notably, appeal to authority and consensus fallacy) in your quest to win the argument. The causes of good science and effective solutions for climate change - both of which I care a lot about - are harmed, not helped, by this style of debate. I recently heard of the term "Steel man" argument, which is the opposite of "Straw man". With a "Steel man" argument, you demonstrate your sincere commitment to finding truth by taking a charitable view of your opponent's position and arguing against the most formidable version of it. If you were to try that on this topic, perhaps you might start by going through the list of scientists named on this Wikipedia page [1], and understanding the basis and the details of each of their reasons for skepticism (it varies a lot between them). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_scientists_opposing_the_mainstream_scientific_assessment_of_global_warming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_scientists_opposing_th...