6 ms·
>The good parts, like covering pre-existing conditions is exactly what causes your insurance to go up. It's basic economics. It is really as simple as that. C
by slg 10y ago
>The good parts, like covering pre-existing conditions is exactly what causes your insurance to go up. It's basic economics.
It is really as simple as that. Could you imagine a system in which car insurance wasn't mandated but car insurance companies were required to repair your car regardless of its preexisting condition? No smart person would preemptively buy insurance. You just wait until your get into an accident and then bring the already damaged car to the insurance company and demand a policy to repair it. No insurance company can work like that.
Insurance only works when the costs of the most expensive customers are shared among the cheapest customers. You need incentives to encourage the cheap customers to sign up or the whole system falls apart. Rejecting preexisting conditions is the old capitalist way of incentivizing people, but as soon as that is prohibited nearly all incentives disappear for a healthy person to buy into the system.
- Judson 10y agoTaking it a step further, I would argue that it ceases to be an 'insurance' product if allowed to purchase after the insured event has passed. Our failure to find a non-insurance 'hammer' with which to hit all of the health 'nails' is a larger issue.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Taking it a step further, I would argue that it ceases to be an 'insurance' product if allowed to purchase after the insured event has passed. You can offer insurance against an event that has already occurred, but the insured price will always be slightly higher than the uninsured price. One could call that insurance, but it'd be a degenerate case, so at that point it's more of a word puzzle than a real question. > Our failure to find a non-insurance 'hammer' with which to hit all of the health 'nails' is a larger issue. Exactly - the problem is that people talk about health insurance like it's supposed to solve the problems that a wealth redistribution program would. Except, insurance is not a wealth redistribution mechanism - it has a completely different goal - and trying to turn it into one just results into the worst of all worlds (expensive and ineffective at achieving either goal).
- jameshart 10y agoI'm not sure what you mean by 'wealth redistribution' in this sense, unless you regard 'good health' as a form of wealth. The only wealth redistribution that is facilitated by insurance is from sick people to medical insurers and providers.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> I'm not sure what you mean by 'wealth redistribution' in this sense, unless you regard 'good health' as a form of wealth. The only wealth redistribution that is facilitated by insurance is from sick people to medical insurers and providers. Pretend for a moment that everyone receives their annual physical, as medical guidelines recommend. (They don't, but it makes our example simpler.) And let's say that the fair-market price of providing the physical, accounting for all costs borne by the provider and their practice, is $100. (That is an arbitrary number I have chosen, also to make our lives easier). What will be the co-pay for the annual physical for an insured patient? The answer is that it will be $100 - there is absolutely no risk involved in this situation, so the expected payouts of the insurance company will be $100, and therefore they will incorporate that into their price. (The consumer will actually pay a bit more than $100 in total, because the insurance company has overhead costs, which are ultimately paid by the consumers as well). But of course, that's not the case, because the expectation is that health insurance will reduce these costs, and that people who can't necessarily afford $100 will still be able to have their physical. That's why health insurance isn't really insurance, except in name - we talk about it as insurance, but in reality, it's a wealth redistribution program tacked onto a risk smoothing product. By definition, insurance is literally not intended to save the insured person money, in expectation. The expected value of all claims will always be less than the expected value of all money paid to the insurer by the insured entity. (This does not hold for every individual, but it does hold in the aggregate - that's where the risk smoothing comes in). The insured person pays the insurer a premium[0] in order to reduce the uncertainty in how much they would have to pay on any given month without insurance. [0] Not as in "monthly premium", but as in "a premium on top of the expected value"
- jameshart 10y ago
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Insurance only works when the costs of the most expensive customers are shared among the cheapest customers. That is not insurance. That is a wealth redistribution. Those are not the same thing, although the current discourse around health insurance conflates those two concepts, for obvious political reasons. > Could you imagine a system in which car insurance wasn't mandated but car insurance companies were required to repair your car regardless of its preexisting condition? No smart person would preemptively buy insurance. You just wait until your get into an accident and then bring the already damaged car to the insurance company and demand a policy to repair it. No insurance company can work like that. Actually, this would be completely feasible to implement. The insurance company would price you based on your risk. In this case, P(risky event | all available information) = 1), so there wouldn't be much of a point to buying the insurance, but it absolutely would work. The problem is that the ACA also forbids insurers from underwriting plans based on anything other than age, income, zip code, and whether or not they smoke. That's guaranteed to increase the cost both for healthy and for unhealthy patients, because they have to make overly conservative estimates when evaluating the risk level of their patient pool.
- slg 10y ago>That is not insurance. That is a wealth redistribution. Those are not the same thing, although the current discourse around health insurance conflates those two concepts, for obvious political reasons. Yes, they are the same thing. Insurance is fundamentally a redistribution of risk with money being shifted from those who have not fallen victim to that risk to those who have. If you have a problem with that aspect of the ACA, you have a problem with the general idea of insurance. >The insurance company would price you based on your risk (in this case, it would be 100%), so there wouldn't be much of a point to buying the insurance, but it absolutely would work. You do realize that this is functionally the same as getting rid of the preexisting conditions protection, right? Whether someone pays tens of thousands to a doctor for care or to an insurance company for coverage are in practice exactly the same. The whole point is that many of us think that is a fundamentally unfair system to force someone to face in that situation.
- chimeracoder 10y ago
- abalone 10y ago> You need incentives to encourage the cheap customers to sign up True. And the ACA now levies a tax penalty for those that don't sign up for insurance (2.5% of income, max ~$2K).[1] [1] https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/health/how-much-is-the-obamacare-penalty-not-having-health-insurance/ https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/health/how-much-is-the-obama...
- douche 10y ago> Insurance only works when the costs of the most expensive customers are shared among the cheapest customers. You need incentives to encourage the cheap customers to sign up or the whole system falls apart And they screwed that part up. As a healthy young person, there is no incentive to buy massively overpriced, shitty high-deductible ACA plans, when one month of coverage costs more than the IRS penalty.
- md2be 10y agoThere is a solution to this paradox. If individuals without insurance were required to repay, at the time of their death, the cost of their healthcare over the last 5 years of life, the economic incentives would change overnight. We already do this and more when it comes to assisted living facilities.
- sokoloff 10y agoHow is that a solution? OK, I'm about to die. I racked up $600K in medical care expenses (or $100K or 'pick a number'). I'm broke and don't have that money. What are you going to do? Not let me die?