2 ms·
I repeat, attributing more significance to observed similarities than observed differences is a social construct. One minute we're talking about fairly obvious
by notahacker 10y ago
I repeat, attributing more significance to observed similarities than observed differences is a social construct. One minute we're talking about fairly obvious visible differences like Korean-descended people almost invariably having paler skin and narrower eyes than Bantu-descended people. You also mentioned stature, which is rather less helpful to your thesis because there's a huge range of average heights between different Bantu subgroups and on average North Koreans are substantially shorter than their genetically difficult-to-distinguish southern cousins. Except for someone like Ri Myung-hun, who's over 7'8". Would one say his stature is best evaluated by analysis of the average height of people bearing "Korean" genetic markers or using a tape measure?
And of course, inevitably you move on to pretending that the huge and stable variation in measured test performance within a population is of lesser import than relatively small and unstable difference in average test performance between populations. Even if we grant the rather silly proposition that tests so unstable that the Dutch population improved by more than a standard deviation in thirty years are actually a good measure of innate intellectual differences unaffected by non-genetic factors, you've got the problem that it's impossible to predict with any degree of certainty what the person who took the test's genetic background actually is. I mean why would anyone interested in investigating innate intelligence choose to focus on genetic markers that predict my skin tone pretty accurately but can't even rule out the possibility of me being in the very top or very bottom percentile for results in any cognitive ability test?
- fdsaaf 10y ago> relatively small and unstable difference in average test performance between populations I'm glad that you at least acknowledge that group differences exist. I think you'd be surprised at the magnitude of the group differences: US white and black populations differ by a full standard deviation as measured by contemporary IQ tests; this difference has been stable since at least the 1970s --- the Flynn effect changes the absolute scores, but not the difference. This difference is stable even when we subtract the effect of environment (e.g., adoption studies). No, it's not stereotype threat either: stereotype threat is one of those convenient social science theories of recent years that rests on experiments that happen not to reproduce. That is, it's bullshit. > attributing more significance to observed similarities than observed difference Significance depends on our purpose. For example, take technology: tech is a high-IQ field. We want people on the right side of the standard distribution. Some population groups (usually identified with races) are under-represented in tech, and many people have called this situation a "problem". The standard narrative is that prejudice and discrimination cause differences in representation and that the appropriate remedy is to take extra, unfair-to-individual steps to bring representation in line with the general population. This line of thinking inevitably leads us to the concept of "privilege", "unconscious bias", and in the end, because none of these measures actually work, we're left with brute-force quotas, unfairness, and resentment. The problem with the standard narrative is that it's built on the assumption that all groups have equal IQ distributions. If we relax this constraint, a simpler theory emerges: tail effects matter; the current system treats individuals fairly; differences in representation reflect real population differences. I'd prefer to look at individuals as, well, individuals, but some people have made racial representation an issue. These people picked a scientific fight, not people like me. It so happens that science is not on the side of the endless discrimination narrative. It's only to defend against charges of racism that we need to study racial IQ distributions at all.
- notahacker 10y ago> the Flynn effect changes the absolute scores, but not the difference. I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest that if a test indicates that me and my fellow white English thirtysomethings produce average scores a standard deviation ahead of (i) thirtysomething black people living in my country and (ii) my white grandparents' generation when they were my age, what's actually measured by the observed one standard deviation average differences across cohorts probably isn't genetic differences....