7 ms·
I've always disliked how right-wing parties automatically get to enjoy the assumption that they are "business-friendly". That's not the case -- their policies t
by pavlov 10y ago
I've always disliked how right-wing parties automatically get to enjoy the assumption that they are "business-friendly". That's not the case -- their policies tend to be friendly to existing big businesses, but may be deeply hostile to new or merely potential businesses.
This list of founders who were able to make the leap thanks to ACA's safety net is a case in point. Under Republican policies, these businesses would not exist.
- adrianparsons 10y agoSimilarly, I wonder what awesome things could be done if we didn't spend such a high percentage of our GDP on health care.
- verelo 10y agoSame. Probably a similar economic outcomes to what would happen if we didn't provide sanitation / water services to the general population.
- nickff 10y agoThese problems are all a result of the huge tax benefit given to employer-provided healthcare; if we got rid of that or extended it to apply to individual plans as well (and hopefully allowed people to purchase out-of-state insurance), it would reduce costs, and allow for more job freedom. I would also personally rather have health insurance actually act as insurance, where you are granted the coverage at the time of diagnosis, rather than having the insurer gradually pay for treatment, but this is unlikely to come to pass.
- lsiebert 10y agoA tax benefit works only if the person has income to offset. If you are a freelance developer and you get sick with a life threatening or chronic illness or even just injured, you may not be able to work while you are getting treatment. If you want more job freedom, a needs based subsidy based on tax income allows cost shifting from years of productive work and tax earnings to years where you can't work, even if your productive work comes later in life, after treatment. It also provides for those who may never be able to earn enough working to pay for current health insurance, those who are retraining latter in life, and those starting a company.
- nickff 10y agoIf I were campaigning for something similar to what you describe, I might sell it as a refundable tax credit, which would be no change for people with employer-provided healthcare, and a benefit for the unemployed or self-employed.
- khuey 10y agoThis is essentially what the ACA's Premium Tax Credit is.
- cookiecaper 10y agoInsurance is a terrible model for health care. Everyone needs health care. Insurance only works when you have a large pool of persons paying premiums against an at-least-relatively unlikely risk. That might work for things like cancer, but it doesn't really work for anything else. We should not have to have an insurance policy for a doctor check out that weird lump on our thigh or come in and spend 10 seconds pretending to talk to us before scribbling out a prescription for something that vaguely sounds appropriate and walking out. Insurance is what distorts these markets. Patients need to pay doctors directly again. Real competition needs to be returned. Right now, the doctor inflates their bill 5x because they know the insurance is going to talk them down, the insurance talks them down because they know they're going to inflate the bill and not worry about it since it's an insurance company paying out, and round and round we go. There's no reason the market for medical care needs to be different than the market for food, which is cheap and abundant. People often say that you can't can have an efficient medical marketplace because medical care is emergent, but that's usually not true; most medical care, like most meal times, can wait long enough to allow the patient to make a choice between competitors, and providers who charge more than the average demographic in their area can afford will go out of business. The incentive to overcharge for emergent care is countered by the incentive to compete, which has already lead to many "urgent care centers" arising throughout the U.S. Good government regulations that prevent cartels from organizing and causing the markets to freeze up/fail can help. These regulations should include outlawing medical insurance. Whatever the solution is, the current situation is an abject failure. ACA band-aids a couple of warts but it gave us new wounds in the process. Whole thing needs to be torn down and rebooted based on sound market principles.
- k__ 10y agoWe have the same problem here in Germany. The FDP (Free Democratic Party) claims to go for liberal rules so businesses can strive. Somehow this mostly includes rules for big corps, with the remark that they provide employment. Funny thing is, the head of FDP is a guy who burned about 3,4M€ of investment money and federal credit. There are always parties with nice ideas, but when you see who donates money to them, you understand why they can't realize them :\
- resfirestar 10y agoI see it as part of the DC bubble effect. What is considered "pro business" is defined by corporate lobbyists, what is "pro labor" by the unions with the largest bureaucracies, and so on.
- phamilton 10y agoThe ACA increases the opportunities for young people and people with chronic illnesses. By distributing those costs, healthy individuals pay more in premiums, which limit their opportunities. If we are optimizating for overall economic productivity, far more people benefit from not having the ACA.
- bduerst 10y agoNot when you factor in more insured people means less expensive medical costs - i.e. more preventative care and less emergency room visits.
- Amezarak 10y agoI'm not sure it is or will work that way, in practice - the more preventative care, less emergency room part, anyway. The total cost of my health insurance premiums is about 20k/year; some of this is subsidized by my employer. I have a $4500 deductible. The insurance does not pay for anything, outside of preventative care, until I've paid $4500. After that, they contribute 80% up to some number, $7500 I think, and then they contribute 100% until the end of the calendar year. Because I have such a high deductible, and due to the opacity of medical billing, I am not going to the doctor unless I'm pretty sure that not going to the doctor means I'm going to be put out of work or going to die. "Preventative" care is defined very strictly: you get a physical. For example, "preventing" the development of pneumonia by treating your respiratory illness early does not count as preventative care. The best I can do is squirrel away what I can in my HSA...but that's one health catastrophe from being blown away. God forbid I come down with any kind of chronic illness that lasts longer than the calendar year. That said, for the poor population, this is definitely true - Medicaid is a dream compared to private insurance. At least in my state, if you're on Medicaid, you don't even see medical bills. It's really lamentable the states were allowed to turn down the Medicaid expansion - the expansion of public health insurance was the best part of the ACA, in my opinion, and the most regrettable part of the bill is that the public option is not available to everyone.
- bduerst 10y ago
- BurningFrog 10y ago> their policies tend to be friendly to existing big businesses, but may be deeply hostile to new or merely potential businesses. There is a big distinction between "pro free enterprise" and "pro business". The former supports capitalism, the latter crony capitalism. > Under Republican policies, these businesses would not exist I think the GOP has yet to figure out what their health care policy even is. They really need to figure out how to be for something again.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoThey are for free market radicalism. It can hardly be considered "conservative" but it is certainly for something.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> They are for free market radicalism. It can hardly be considered "conservative" but it is certainly for something. Neither party is really in favor of free markets in any meaningful sense. The GOP happens to use that rhetoric more than the Democrats do in order to gain support for their policies, but knowing how to leverage the rhetoric doesn't mean that's what they actually support, if you look at their actions.
- lsiebert 10y agoI really think the GOP needs to go with evidence based policy analysis. If they think they can come up with a better health care system, fine, but what are the metrics for better? health care costs have gone up way past the amount of inflation, and to some extent that makes sense, because there are new treatments, but it seems like tax breaks are not going to help the working poor to the same extent that the ACA subsidies and medicare expansion do.
- nerfhammer 10y agoThe GOP essentially came up with the ACA in the first place.
- 10y ago
- misnome 10y ago"Pro Business" means, "Pro-me" which means, "Pro to the businesses that bribe^H^H^H^H^Hlobby me.
- tasty_freeze 10y agoThere is also the mantra that Republicans are the party of small government and fiscal responsibility. Nope, the difference between Democrats and Republicans is what they want to spend the money on. This is just a fact, easily verified by looking at the debt across decades of various administrations and congressional alignments. A few years ago Ted Cruz and company very nearly shut down the government and defaulted on the national debt, insisting that raising it was irresponsible and laying it at the feet of President Obama. They insisted any increase in spending had to be offset by a cut somewhere else. Sounds like a really bold, principled stand. Then this: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/dispatches/2017/01/11/republican-budget-bill-raises-debt-ceiling-10-trillion/ http://www.patheos.com/blogs/dispatches/2017/01/11/republica... Now that Republicans are fully in charge, they just authorized an escalating increase of the debt limit, running from $580B/year (2017) to $946B/year (2026), or a $10T increase over the next 10 years. There was no dissent, it was just quietly passed. I'm not saying it was wrong or irresponsible to do -- I'm just saying the politics are transparent, if they weren't already.
- enraged_camel 10y agoWe also know for a fact that Republicans aren't in favor of the government staying out of people's private lives. They are, after all, strongly anti-abortion, which by definition is an extremely private affair. edit: what I said is 100% correct, so I will assume that the downvotes are simply political in nature.
- MrZongle2 10y ago"We also know for a fact that Republicans aren't in favor of the government staying out of people's private lives." I think it's pretty clear at this point that both parties love getting involved in the private affairs of individuals. Obama continued Bush-era spying policies, and in fact just this week (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13390511 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13390511) expanded the power of the intelligence community to snoop on Americans. Blaming just one political party is demonstrable nonsense.
- 10y ago