6 ms·
It seems like this would be an instance where the government should provide the funding. It's in the public's best interest to have at least one anti-venom prod
by pyre 17y ago
It seems like this would be an instance where the government should provide the funding. It's in the public's best interest to have at least one anti-venom product available. It makes no sense to tell people "tough luck" when they get bitten just because it's too expensive to pay for the studies to get government approval.
- earl 17y agoWell, until it has been tested, it is neither tried nor proven. And here is but a single reason http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide for such testing requirements. Edit: to be clear, I was attempting to respond to the parent's parent post. I apparently suck at internet.
- barrkel 17y agoThe use case for an antivenom based on known working precedents, where the untreated alternative is death, is somewhat different to sedatives used generally to treat colds, coughs, morning sickness, etc.
- earl 17y agoNo. Read the article -- in the example used, the alternative is weeks on a ventilator. Which we know works. Until these drugs are known to be efficacious with tolerable side effects, they are still a second best treatment.
- pyre 17y agoWhat if you are too far away from a facility that can provide that for you? Having a syringe of anti-venom with you can be the difference between life and death.
- evgen 17y agoThere is no facility you will encounter that has the anti-venom but does not have a ventilator. This is not like an epi-pen or some other OTC med that a backpacker will carry with them, it is a hospital-dispensed, fucking expensive dose of medicine (e.g. rattlesnake anti-venom is around $4K/bottle.) But why let reality get in the way of a good rant I guess...
- pyre 17y agoHow could you classify my comment as a rant? I realize that 'tone' doesn't really translate well through text and you might read my comment as an attack (which it wasn't), but how can a couple of sentences be a 'rant?' I would think that a rant would have to be at least a few sentences or more (or some sort of absolute character/word limit in the case of large run-on sentences). If you felt it was made in anger or hate, I would think it would classify as a retort or something similar.
- pyre 17y ago> Edit: to be clear, I was attempting to respond to the parent's parent post. I apparently suck at internet. Something weird happened. When I originally posted, your comment was a sibling post to mine (and was already a child of the root of this thread after the page reload from submitting my comment). I was surprised when I came back to this thread to see your comment a child to my comment.
- Gormo 17y agoOr simply revoke the patent for these antivenoms so that companies that don't have the same opportunity costs can enter the niche. I think it would solve a lot of other problems (e.g. submarine patents) if patent holders were required (within defined bounds) to offer their patented products for sale on the open market in order to retain the patent.
- brg 17y agoAs much as you may be against software patents, there can be no current patent restriction on the production of coral-snake antivenom if it was approved in 1967. The problem described in the article is simply that so few bites occur, the effort to make antivenom is not interesting to anyone with the skills or equipment to make it. This includes individual pharmacists, university scientists, and corporations; all of who can but do not provide antivenom.
- Gormo 17y agoThat's a good point; I didn't make the connection with the 1967 date and focused on the article referencing that one company as the only source of antivenom. Is it possible for pharmacists to synthesize anti-venom on demand? Coral snake bites may be rare, but if you were, for example, the operator of an Everglades tour group, your probability of encountering a bite might be a bit higher, and the antivenom would be good to keep around.
- sigstoat 17y agoyou'd probably want an organic synthesis chemist, not a pharmacist. and you wouldn't have time for him to have the appropriate glassware fabricated, and synthesis equipment setup. so he'd have to leave a room with it all step up properly. ...which sounds like the sort of thing you might do if you were just manufacturing it.
- brg 17y agoPerhaps originally I should have said pharmacologist, but even in retrospect your term of a specialized chemist seems more correct.