3 ms·
Almost. The way you've described only works if the ACME user also has access to the private key for the CSR. But that isn't true if you're using CSRs from some
by tialaramex 10y ago
Almost.
The way you've described only works if the ACME user also has access to the private key for the CSR. But that isn't true if you're using CSRs from some appliance you bought which doesn't let you change or view its private keys and doesn't implement ACME itself. That's a good secure design for the appliance so we don't want to discourage it.
Thus, ACME doesn't do it that way. It has a separate key pair for the ACME protocol itself, the "account key" pair. Your challenge signature is signed with the private key for the ACME account. The ACME client never needs to know the private key for a CSR it presents, although in the easy-to-use default modes in popular clients like Certbot they do generate these keys too.