5 ms·
Simulations suggest Planet Nine may have been a rogue
- Phithagoras 10y agoAbstract at http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2017AAS...22942405V http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2017AAS...22942405V
- jessriedel 10y agoActually, Phys.org is one of the few commendable popular science sites that quotes the abstract at the end of the article.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> They presented evidence suggesting that if Planet Nine is out there, it is likely a rogue. But the evidence seems kind of sketchy. In their simulations, a rogue was only captured by the Sun 40% of the time. Thats' better than 4%, but still not great. (Or is that actually a really good result? I don't know.) I wonder how long it would be before we could reasonably send a probe to explore a potential rogue. New Horizons managed a fly-by; how plausible would entering orbit around something that far away be with a reasonable time to get there?
- mabbo 10y ago> I wonder how long it would be before we could reasonably send a probe to explore a potential rogue. New Horizons took around a decade to reach Pluto, which is about 50 AU from the sun. The nearest distance Planet 9 could be is approximately 200 AU. Right now, waiting seems to best bet before sending anything, so that we can hopefully find ways to send probes faster and meanwhile try to better identify its location.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoOh sure, I'm not suggesting sending probes just to take a look around. But if we do positively identify another planet and its location, sending a probe there would be fascinating. If we could actually land it and do some materials science on a rogue planet, it would basically double our understanding of planetary formation.
- willglynn 10y agoThe delta-V requirements for landing on an outer solar system body are… intense. New Horizons flew past Pluto at 14 km/s; in order to land, that relative speed would need to become zero. This concept likely requires new propulsion technology. Agreed on being fascinating, though.
- deodorel 10y agoWell if it is a planet 10x the size if earth it might have an atmosphere so we could aerobrake, no?
- T-hawk 10y agoWe've already landed on an outer solar system body, Saturn's moon Titan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens_(spacecraft) Titan does have the advantage of a thick atmosphere to allow descent by parachute, and a large parent body to capture the spacecraft into orbit.
- mabbo 10y agoIt would indeed, but the costs wouldn't make it viable. Spend that same money funding every other effort planetary scientists want to do for years to come. They'll learn far more from those efforts than from the one very expensive probe.
- blincoln 10y agoWould they "learn far more"? I am not a xenogeologist or astrophysicist, but landing a probe on a rogue planet seems like a shortcut to visiting another star system.
- dogma1138 10y agoWe have no idea what is the orbit so the distance doesn't matter there is no way to do a flyby unless we know for sure it's there and can map it's orbit nearly fully otherwise regardless of how fast we are going we'll never get to it :)
- mabbo 10y agoWe actually have a pretty good estimate on the orbit[0], though not necessarily where it is in that orbit (afaik at least). Your point is correct- there's no where to go until we get a fix on it- but your description is technically incorrect. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Nine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Nine
- dogma1138 10y agoWe don't even know for sure it exists we have very little information on the orbit what exactly is incorrect?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hashkb 10y agoIt's the Second Foundation. Duh.
- Insanity 10y agoI'm really curious as to the outcome around this. The idea that a new planet in our solar system is discovered in our lifetime is exciting to me for some reason. I can't even really explain the feeling. Even though for most people the discovery will make no difference, they might not even care about it, which is a shame I think.
- WhoBeI 10y agoYup, and if we do manage to prove it's existence we should keep the name "Planet 9". And pretty please let the math on the star collision in 2022 be correct. I really want to see that.
- Roboprog 10y agoFormerly known as Planet X, before the Pluto demotion kerfuffle. But Plan 9, er Planet, is good, too.
- Codywastaken 10y agoNah, let's call it something fun like Nibiru or Nemesis.
- talktime 10y agoHave you heard of Ceres - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceres_(dwarf_planet) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceres_(dwarf_planet) I learned of it recently and it was like learning of a new planet.
- kareldonk 10y agoThe Sumerians already knew it existed, and much more: https://blog.kareldonk.com/planet-x-nibiru-an-analysis-of-akkadian-seal-va243/ https://blog.kareldonk.com/planet-x-nibiru-an-analysis-of-ak...
- dogma1138 10y agoAncient aliens... yeah mmkay...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]