4 ms·
Groupon overwhelms San Francisco bakery
- jsiarto 17y agoI live in Chicago and have been using Groupon for a while. The last one I bought was 50% off a 1-hour massage and they were booked for 2 months before I could get in to see anyone. Groupon is hugely popular here (obviously)
- djb_hackernews 17y agoI did some math a while ago. They have 50 cities, so 50 deals a day. It looks like the average deal is $20 and the average participation is 1000 signups per deal. So that’s 1Mil in cash flow per day. They keep half (sourced from a friend who did a groupon for her store) so 500K per day revenue. Or about 175M/yr. Which, accounting for my crappy math, accounts for the 1.x billion valuations I see.
- jules 17y agoHalf?! That is huge, I don't understand how that could be a good deal for the people using Groupon, and a very good opportunity for a competitor.
- djb_hackernews 17y agoIt's not a good deal in the short term. I imagine the sales pitch to frequently mention repeat customers, brand awareness, and attention. Then I bet they tell them to take whatever it would cost to break even, and double it, that will be the groupon price. As the article mentions, Groupon has plenty of competitors, with probably room for more.
- minouye 17y agoThe problem with the sales pitch is I don't know how much insight Groupon has into the long-term lift they'll give customers (i.e. how much historical data do they have?). Groupon's pricing seems like it would have to be a stab in the dark--they can't possibly know the nuances of all the businesses they deal with (massage purchasing behavior will differ from helicopter ride purchases). I feel bad for Mom and Pop operations because a massive increase in sales without proper planning could materially hurt their business.
- kadavy 17y agoIn some cases, they take ALL of it (just because the mailing list exposure is that powerful).
- edash 17y agoGroupon is a form of advertising. You could advertise in print, on Yelp or elsewhere and pay money out without knowing whether a customer will actually use your business. Even with PPC you rarely have the ability to track to the sale for businesses like this (restaurants, salons, action sports, entertainment etc). With Groupon, you don't pay a cent. Instead, you just price your goods/services at break even and get hundreds of new customers in the door. If even a small percentage become repeat business, that still seems like a pretty good idea. Underpricing a free (for consumers) service, on the other hand, seems like a terrible idea for a business.
- retube 17y agoYeah, it's incredible. Had I had this idea, and had been considering my cut, I'd probably have plumped for 5% or 10% or 15%. After all this is what most online retailers charge. I would have imagined that at 50% everyone would have laughed at them. Mind you, that's why I'm poor and those guys now have a billion dollar company.
- Jun8 17y agoA lot of businesses would like to have the problem this bakery is facing :-) I don't think Groupon has an upper limit of customers, they should add this feature. Also, I'm wondering if they offer analytics advice (for a small fee, of course) to their biz customers, e.g. for this type of deal in this location, you are expecting to get on the average N customers.
- djb_hackernews 17y agoAny business could have the problem this bakery is facing, all they have to do is deeply discount their product and hope they have enough capital to ride it out. It's not sustainable.
- Jun8 17y agoThe hefty fee that Groupon can extoll from their users shows that it's not that easy in practice.
- kixxauth 17y agoQuote from Inc Mag article: Others grouse about Groupon's fee. "It's a bold thing for a company to make 50 percent for essentially hawking an e-mail list," says Lincecum. Mason makes no apologies. "We have a waiting list of hundreds of businesses in our larger cities," he says. "Demand is much higher than supply. If I remember high school economics correctly, that means our margin is too low."
- kadavy 17y agoThere was a deal a couple of weeks ago that I was considering getting in on. I went back at 2pm, and the deal was closed - so I think they do have an upper limit on customers.
- woodrow 17y agoAnother Groupon experience -- Groupon overwhelms Boston helicopter training school: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2010/03/19/groupon-marketing-results/ http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2010/03/19/groupon-market... EDIT: I should add that this is a blog post written by someone heavily involved in their operations, so there's a reasonable amount of detail.
- steveplace 17y agoI've wanted to start a business that does this but with nightclubs and SMS. Good vertical and clear exit (sell to groupon, of course!) Anyone game?
- pchristensen 17y agoSee also Phil Greenspun's experience: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2010/03/19/groupon-marketing-results/ http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2010/03/19/groupon-market... "Starting just after 6 am, Groupon sent out emails to its roughly 200,000 Boston subscribers. I knew that there might be a problem when I checked a few minutes after receiving my email (I am a subscriber). They'd already sold 30. By 11:00 am, they'd sold more than 2000. We finally had to beg them to shut it down at 2600 (we could have set a limit initially but didn’t think to)."