14 ms·
I don't think he is a denier, I honestly believe he is poking fun at the supremely confident masses who are absolutely sure climate change is precisely as the s
by mistermann 10y ago
I don't think he is a denier, I honestly believe he is poking fun at the supremely confident masses who are absolutely sure climate change is precisely as the scientists say, and that anyone that disagress in the slightest is a denier/idiot/whatever. He also happens to be correct, the general public doesn't understand the intricacies of climate change.
I'm no denier either, but you'll have to pardon me if I choose to not join the unthinking hordes who insist we must do something now, and no we will not think while we are doing this. Dissension is explicitly not allowed.
Oh, is that not exaaaaaaaaaaaactly what the message is? Of course not, but there is some truth there. There are highly trained scientists who don't fully support the party line, and they are not allowed to speak. I believe it is not an intellectually honest conversation, and I'm old enough to remember other situations where dissent was not allowed and it turned out not so good.
Also, don't forget that Scott is a humorist author, and part of his schtick is to deliberately cause outrage, especially with people who take themselves way too seriously.
- E6300 10y agoIf you get diagnosed with cancer, would you go to med school and wait until you graduate and can fully understand the diagnosis and how the prescribed treatment was arrived at by your doctor before you follow it, or would you follow the treatment as closely as possible as soon as possible? Perhaps climate scientists don't know with completely precision everything there is to know about climate change. But as far as anyone can tell no one has a more accurate picture. "This theory may be imperfect [not even 'is imperfect'; we just don't know] so we should disregard it completely" is a Nirvana fallacy.
- mistermann 10y ago> Perhaps climate scientists don't know with completely precision everything there is to know about climate change. Don't be surprised when people don't trust you if you don't disclose that fact.
- DonHopkins 10y agoSays the guy who brings bullshit to a discussion about calling bullshit.
- mistermann 10y agoOh, which bullshit was that?
- DonHopkins 10y agoYou claimed that Judith Curry was "not allowed to speak", for example. Here's something she allowed herself to speak: "Once we get over this little bump of activism, if the Trump administration will put us on a slightly reassuring and saner footing, that will allow all this to die down," she said. "We can always hope." -Judith Curry http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060047798 http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060047798 Good luck with that long term plan that depends on Trump putting us on a saner footing! Are you really sure she isn't allowed to speak? She's on FOX News an awful lot. And is it really true that people blink when they're lying? Starting at 3:00 I counted Judith Curry blinking 85 times in 60 seconds during this recent Tucker Carson interview on FOX News. At that rate, she must have blinked 387 times during that 4:33 minute interview! Forget about the Butterfly Effect: her eyelash fluttering itself could affect global climate patterns! https://youtu.be/g5LpwL4NKbw?t=3m0s https://youtu.be/g5LpwL4NKbw?t=3m0s
- mistermann 10y agoIf you literally interpret me, the police should have been called because not being allowed to utter a single word anywhere would be a major human rights abuse. I could say to you: why are you talking about mammal excrement? Oh, "of course" I shouldn't have used that interpretation of the word, right? Will you extend the same courtesy to me?
- DonHopkins 10y agoThe topic of this discussion is "Calling bullshit". Will you define exactly what you mean by the term "not allowed to speak", and list the names of scientists who were not allowed to speak?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DonHopkins 10y ago>I'm no [...], but [...]. [1] Also, don't forget that Trump is a reality TV show host, and part of his schtick is to deliberately cause outrage, especially with people who take themselves way too seriously. [1] http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/I'm_not_prejudiced,_but.. http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/I'm_not_prejudiced,_but...
- yongjik 10y ago> There are highly trained scientists who don't fully support the party line, and they are not allowed to speak. Name one.
- DonHopkins 10y agoNobody knows their names, because they're not allowed to speak.
- mistermann 10y agoJudith Curry https://judithcurry.com/2017/01/03/jc-in-transition/ https://judithcurry.com/2017/01/03/jc-in-transition/ Look at how this mildly (at best) informed senator encounters facts that don't support his hypothesis, look at how he, an amateur, speaks to a top scientist! I believe many if not most scientists are at least partially lying to people, and by lying I don't mean they are accidentally mistaken, I mean that they know that some of what they are saying is speculative, but they pass it off as established fact. I look forward to stopping thinking this way when the scientific community admits to this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oh6zDbWMuP0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oh6zDbWMuP0 I suppose (sigh) that I must pre-emptively add that no, indeed, she wasn't in fact literally prevented from speaking. I'll leave it as an exercise to the reader to decide for themselves whether all is well in this situation.
- DonHopkins 10y agoYou failed to prove she was "not allowed to speak" by posting a link to a video of her literally SPEAKING in front of Congress. Did somebody interrupt her, and that's the best proof you can come up with of your assertion "There are highly trained scientists who don't fully support the party line, and they are not allowed to speak." Being highly criticized by your peers is not the same as not being allowed to speak. Do you have any better examples of scientists who were not allowed to speak -- perhaps a scientist who hasn't actually testified in front of Congress on live national television, written an op-ed for the Wall Street Journal, boasts of having a total of 12,000 citations of her publications, and a blog that gets on average about 12,000 ‘hits’ per day, and 300-400 comments? Or is that all you've got?
- ranit 10y ago> Also, don't forget that Scott is a humorist author, and part of his schtick is to deliberately cause outrage, especially with people who take themselves way too seriously. Fair point. Could you find a link where he "deliberately causes outrage" to the opposite camp that "take themselves also too seriously" completely denying the same science theory. I am genuinely curious, because up until recently I also had similar opinion about him (a humorist author approach). Now, I kind of doubt this.
- mistermann 10y agoMuch of what he has written in the last maybe 3 or 4 weeks I find....distasteful? I absolutely love a good troll, I think he used to be that, but in my opinion he has changed into something less appealing. I still read him though because I think he continues to raise interesting points (if not always valid) and observations, but I (as someone mostly on "his side" of the political spectrum) often find what he writes a bit repulsive.
- DonHopkins 10y ago>"I absolutely love a good troll" -misterman You're not a good troll.