4 ms·
What exactly was Newton risking? An entrepreneur who quits her job and takes out a mortgage to start a business is risking her livelihood. If she fails, she a
by lisper 10y ago
What exactly was Newton risking? An entrepreneur who quits her job and takes out a mortgage to start a business is risking her livelihood. If she fails, she and her family could end up on the street. Newton came from a wealthy family. If he failed in his intellectual endeavors the "risk" for him was to live out his life as an ordinary rich person and only ending up in the more obscure history books.
I think Fredrick Smith (founder of Fedex) is a much better example of someone taking an entrepreneurial and intellectual risk.
http://about.van.fedex.com/our-story/history-timeline/history/ http://about.van.fedex.com/our-story/history-timeline/histor...
- CaptSpify 10y agoI may be mis-understanding the authors intent, but I don't see him as saying that Newton risked wealth or comfort, rather that he risked time-spent on fruitful endeavors.
- jaredhansen 10y agoHe was risking his time and attention in studying it. The opportunity cost is nontrivial, especially if you have the kind of IQ Newton had.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- empath75 10y agoOpportunity cost
- ConfuciusSay02 10y agoGood point, and there's evidence to support the fact that the main indicator of a successful entrepreneur, is if he or his family is wealthy.
- gwern 10y agoNewton's theology was extremely heretical (to all major religious factions, as he was an anti-Trinitarian!) at a time when religious politics in England were brutal and could easily be fatal; being expelled from Cambridge for violating the religion oaths/tests would've only been the start. And, incidentally, alchemy was, besides being highly disreputable & associated with con artists, illegal in England for centuries before and for most of Newton's career: punishable by death and then confiscation of the deceased's estate (Levere, _Transforming Matter: A History of Chemistry from Alchemy to the Buckyball_). So if the full extent of Newton's activities & beliefs had been known, he could have lost his good name, job, life, and any family wealth. So what exactly was Newton risking? Everything.
- pdm55 10y agoGood points. His position must have been tenuous anyway as it was a requirement of Cambridge that all Fellows become ordained Anglican priests. Newton only avoided this by special exemption from Charles II and it is not likely that he could afford to be exposed as breaking other regulations. Maybe this is part of the reason he was so reluctant to publish, he may have wondered if his physical reasoning could be construed as somehow against the prevailing religious beliefs of the time, especially when you see the approbation Newton's intellectual predecessor Galileo suffered for his new physics.
- lisper 10y agoBut you are actually making my point for me. Opportunity cost is a vacuous argument. Everything you do has an opportunity cost. That's not a risk, it's just a consequence of the laws of physics. Maybe publishing would have counted as taking a risk for the reasons you cite, but Newton resisted publishing for a very long time, so he was actually avoiding that risk. So once again it really seems to me that Newton is not a good example of the merits of taking risks. (Quite the contrary in fact.)
- oh_sigh 10y agoNewton's family was not well off. His father, a yeoman, died before he was born, his mother remarried a reverend, who also died before Newton came of age. His mother wanted him to be a farmer, which is not lucrative unless you have huge tracts of land(which he did not). When he was first admitted to Trinity, he was a subsizar - that is, he had to perform valet duties in order to pay for his education. He only stopped doing those duties when he was awarded a scholarship.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lisper 10y agoWell, my source was: http://www.history.com/news/history-lists/9-things-you-may-not-know-about-isaac-newton http://www.history.com/news/history-lists/9-things-you-may-n... "When Newton was three, his mother wed a wealthy clergyman, Barnabas Smith..." "In 1705, Newton was knighted by Queen Anne. By that time, he’d become wealthy after inheriting his mother’s property..." Newton's mother died in 1679, when Newton was 37. Principia was published in 1687.