3 ms·
This was submitted by the author a few days ago, but it gained no upvotes, and only one comment. The comment was mine, and I repeat it here. The "you" in this
by ColinWright 10y ago
This was submitted by the author a few days ago, but it gained no upvotes, and only one comment. The comment was mine, and I repeat it here. The "you" in this comment is the author:
On this I beg to differ. Or at least, you are making a sweeping generalisation. Not everyone thinks and feels as you do.
For me, being given "historical context" and having to understand where these things came from, or why they were interesting, or how they were developed, or who did them, was tedious agony, and I hated it with a passion that's hard to describe.
I understand that for some people it brings mathematics to life, for others, like me, it kills it. Please don't think everyone is like you.
- endswapper 10y agoThe author's statements are reasonable. I am surprised by your comment as well as the need to repost it. He's taking the time to remind us of the richness beyond the technical understanding of mathematics. I think this is a good reminder, in particular, for a technically proficient audience that may spend the majority of their time on technical matters. Nowhere did he say that we should be historians or encyclopedias of/for mathematics. At worst, his point stimulates an additional portion of our brains and may make mathematics more accessible to some. The title might be hyperbolic, but it's effective.
- ColinWright 10y agoI am surprised at your surprise. All I'm saying is that for me, what the author proposes would have been strongly counter-productive. I'm sure I'm not alone in this. I'm sure some students would benefit, I'm sure others, equally, would not. I just wanted to be sure that the complementary point of view was expressed, especially since it affects me personally. The title might be hyperbolic, but it's effective. Actually, I disagree with the title. Mathematics has a life and soul of its own separately and independently of its history. The real problem is that in school one doesn't actually study mathematics anyway, one mostly does arithmetic and manipulation. Perhaps for many students the problem lies not in understanding the history, but in not doing mathematics to start with.