3 ms·
If we really care about net neutrality, we should focus on privacy. If we build the internet so that it hides the destination data from the carrier, net neutral
by dahart 10y ago
If we really care about net neutrality, we should focus on privacy. If we build the internet so that it hides the destination data from the carrier, net neutrality will automatically happen as a byproduct, and we don't need the FCC or have to care about different backbone networks.
We should stop arguing that AT&T should be legally barred from doing something with the data it has access to, and start making it so that AT&T doesn't have access to that data.
- tremon 10y agoWe should stop arguing that AT&T should be legally barred from doing something with the data it has access to Why should we stop arguing that? The postal service operates under the same constraints.
- dahart 10y agoI thought I explained that in the remainder of my sentence, but I'll go ahead and clarify that I do think AT&T should be legally barred, but I also think it's a waste of time to argue about it. It's a question of effectiveness and of time & energy and how to best spend it. Why spend time asking lawmakers for net neutrality regulation, when instead we could do what we do best as engineers and build the network such that net neutrality and privacy is built in. Then we don't have to sit around hoping that AT&T and others are not tempted to seek ways to make money. Why spend time writing articles that complain about the Republican pro-industry FCC, when we have the power amongst ourselves to build a better internet and take the question of net neutrality off the table entirely? The USPS analogy is a bit apples to oranges; the USPS is a government organization and AT&T is one of many private for-profit entities that carry our digital communication. Furthermore, AT&T already was legally barred from listening to conversations going through their network and they did it anyway. I don't exactly trust them, even if there are laws. I don't think we should expect companies to not try to make money. Their function is to try to make money. If they see ways to try to make money, by asking consumers to pay extra for faster connections to Netflix, they should be allowed to offer premium services. A big problem with the question of net neutrality is that it's subjective. It's fair to say they're slowing people down if they don't pay more. It's also fair to say they're just offering premium service for a premium fee. These is no winning this argument, both sides have valid arguments. Focusing on privacy instead will answer a question that has a clearer "right" answer, and it will automatically yield a network that has net neutrality built in.
- spinlock 10y agoI think this is a great point. Expecting companies not to act in their own best interest is foolish. It's also foolish to expect our elected officials to act in the citizens' best interest rather than for their donors. Instead, let's make net Neutrality the only option so we can focus on technical challenges.