5 ms·
You'd also need a much larger number of the solar powered drones to cover the same area as a satellite. They don't make it clear but I'd guess one of the main i
by rtkwe 10y ago
You'd also need a much larger number of the solar powered drones to cover the same area as a satellite. They don't make it clear but I'd guess one of the main issues was getting the radio and networking gear light, small, and low power enough to work in their drone design with enough throughput to make the network vaguely acceptable while covering a large enough area to make the number of drones required reasonable.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoOTOH having to have more drones gives you benefits of economies of scale when you move past testing phase; you can mass-produce a platform and drop the price significantly. Satellites, on the other hand, are mostly one-of-a-kind constructions, produced in single or double-digit numbers. (Also with a fleet of drones, failures are cheaper and less dangerous.) There are lots of factors affecting economics of both solutions. I guess one of these days I'll have to make a spreadsheet with back-of-the-envelope calculations to sort this all out, but my gut feeling for now is that solar drones are a viable replacement for a lot of current satellite uses.
- rtkwe 10y agoMaking more would help but there's still limits on how far down it could possibly drive down the price on this large complex drone. To me the largest issue is simply power, these drones need to store a lot of energy just to fly overnight. Add in the power requirements for all the radio gear, it'll need to operate overnight too to make the service particularly useful, and battery weight can quickly spiral outside of what can reasonably be done by a small company trying to build a small plane. There's also 2 hard competing design goals solar panel area and aerodynamics. The first wants broad flat surfaces to place as many panels as possible on while the second is pushing you towards long thing wings and bodies to reduce drag. I'm not saying these are impossible things to build but I do think it's more in the realm of large aeronautic companies rather than a small division of google.
- vonmoltke 10y agoSatellites built to accomplish the same task as these drones would not be higher volume than that. Neither volume, though, would getuch benefit from scale. Specialty parts that required significant development would be expensive even if the production run was in the thousands.
- SEJeff 10y agoThe SpaceX satellite internet constellation is planned to be around 4425 satellites, not a a few dozen.