6 ms·
This is what comes out of Google allowing apps to read phone IMEI in Android. I have no concrete proof, but the reason why all major Chinese apps snoop after ph
by baybal2 10y ago
This is what comes out of Google allowing apps to read phone IMEI in Android. I have no concrete proof, but the reason why all major Chinese apps snoop after phone IMEI is said to be that the commies have secretly demanded Chinese dotcoms to collect and report phone IMEIs.
For example if you have a 6.0 or later Android, Alibaba app will block you if you disabled the permission to read IMEI or it detects spoofing.
https://postimg.org/image/m5u0nmdxd/ https://postimg.org/image/m5u0nmdxd/
It is easy to see how they also use it for their own purposes: open a new taobao account, search for some items, do factory reset, install taobao and see that you are being shown same stuff you been searching before. This way they also clearly violate Google store rules that prohibit using IMEIs as tracking IDs for marketing purposes. It was reported over so many times, and Google clearly knows of this. I guess, they are afraid of antagonising "the premier Chinese dotcom" or still considering going back to China.
- Inconel 10y agoI'm on 7.1.1 and I don't feel like installing the Alibaba app to try this out but when you say it requires the permission to read IMEI is this under the phone permission setting that says "read phone status and identity" or something else?
- baybal2 10y agoappears that they put it into that now
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- peteretep 10y ago> Google allowing apps to read > phone IMEI in Android An unpopular sentiment, but this is why I love iOS. I genuinely don't think any of my apps can meaningfully spy on me without my having told them they may. I even get reminders if I've let an app read my location in the background, to check that's what I want to do.
- twsted 10y agoNot so unpopular...
- peteretep 10y agoHistorically unpopular :-)
- imcrs 10y agoThis was the primary reason I chose iOS over android.
- bad_user 10y agoEven though I like Android more, I have to agree that iOS has had a better privacy story. But even iOS has problems. For example I cannot force apps like Waze or Uber to only use my location while using them, you have to either disable location for them completely, or to allow them to take your location while running in the background. It's an either/or proposition and the result is that Waze and Uber users do have their location tracked, because the apps are not usable with the location completely disabled and enabling location on demand is too painful. While in traffic, imagine sitting at a red light, wanting to turn on GPS navigation to take you home or something and having to enable location in iOS's settings. And you may have given them permission, you may know about it, but are you going to stop using Waze and Uber if you don't agree? I think I know the answer for most people. And also, even with your permission, as a matter of fact it's still irresponsible to let them track your location in the background, even if you currently trust those companies.
- et-al 10y ago> For example I cannot force apps like Waze or Uber to only use my location while using them, you have to either disable location for them completely, or to allow them to take your location while running in the background. What if one quits the app? Then it's no longer in the background and can't track your location, right?
- peteretep 10y ago
- samstave 10y agoPlease ELI5; What info about your actions can IMEI info/actions give anyone with access?
- TobbenTM 10y agoTracking people (phones) across apps and services.
- chinathrow 10y agoAnd networks. Worldwide.
- rconti 10y agoI'm not really clear on why it's that much worse than having your phone number; with the right access, the phone number is all you need to track a user across global cell networks anyway. Though the IMEI should be exposed to a Stingray type device, so you'd be able to track users without access to the cell networks, you'd just have to set up a bunch of radios. And you wouldn't be able to shake it by swapping SIMs. That said, most users wouldn't bother with changing phone numbers or SIMs.
- pdkl95 10y agoAlso, after paying for or otherwise gaining access to SS7[1], the IMEI may also allow more active types of attack[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_System_No._7 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_System_No._7 [2] https://media.ccc.de/v/31c3_-_6249_-_en_-_saal_1_-_201412271715_-_ss7_locate_track_manipulate_-_tobias_engel https://media.ccc.de/v/31c3_-_6249_-_en_-_saal_1_-_201412271...
- kriro 10y agoOn Android 6.0+ you can deny the READ_PHONE_STATE permission and stop using apps that won't work if you do. A quick search seems to indicate that there is an Alibaba app for iOS. Do you think Apple negotiated that the IMEI isn't required for the iOS version? Personally I don't trust Android (or the hardware companies that sell Android devices) or iOS but picked an Android 6+ device because in principle I'd rather have an operating system that's more open. AFAIK all the Apple privacy stories have been about US cases so as a non-US person I'm also not sure they'd apply the same standards to me.
- masklinn 10y ago> Do you think Apple negotiated that the IMEI isn't required for the iOS version? Didn't need to negotiate anything, on iOS the IMEI has never been programmatically accessible[0], and other "global identifiers" (UDID, MAC) either weren't ever accessible or were removed afterwards. You can get an "advertising identifier" which should only be used to hand to ad networks (your application can get banned if you use it otherwise) and a "vendor identifier" which identifies the device to the app vendor only. [0] via public frameworks, you can get it from the private NetworkController class but that will get your application rejected from the appstore. You're "at risk" if you sideload applications though.
- FabHK 10y agoAnd, BTW, in iOS you can reset the advertising identifier in Settings -> Privacy -> Advertising.