3 ms·
The mainstream media did a fine job. Your criticism is completely misplaced. The New York Times, CNN, Guardian etc all reported the verified facts. Which is th
by threeseed 10y ago
The mainstream media did a fine job. Your criticism is completely misplaced.
The New York Times, CNN, Guardian etc all reported the verified facts. Which is that a report was produced by an ex-MI6 spy looking into allegations that Russia had amongst others compromising video involving prostitutes/golden showers and President Elect Trump. This report was obtained by John McCain and passed to the FBI for verification. They didn't publish the report. They didn't publish the allegations. The presence and gist of the report is newsworthy because the spy in question has by all accounts impeccable credentials which McCain and the CIA/FBI made statements about. That is all they reported.
BuzzFeed were the ones who decided to publish the report and all of the above organisations heavily criticised them for it afterwards questioning their ethics etc.
- mcintyre1994 10y agoI don't see why Buzzfeed are being criticised for it either, because they only reported verified facts - that the report was going around, that it was neither verified or falsified, that it contained errors and falsehoods. I imagine the others are just annoyed Buzzfeed jumped first when they all had it so they're criticising them.
- collias 10y agoWouldn't pushing a story that was "neither verified or falsified", be considered "fake news", by some definition?
- threeseed 10y agoFake news means that the story was deliberately made up. Nobody did that in this case. The report was verified to be written by the ex-MI6 spy. The claims in the report are what are yet to be verified.
- mcintyre1994 10y ago"By some definition", sure. I have no idea what the definition of fake news is (I just made a comment saying I have no idea what it is at this point), but I expect that some definitions being used would include buzzfeed yep.
- bobcostas55 10y ago>They didn't publish the report. They didn't publish the allegations. That just makes it worse, doesn't it? The actual allegations are so insane it's obvious they're fake. By hiding them, they make it appear credible.
- nl 10y agoWait, what? So if they do publish the report (ie, Buzzfeed) then they get blamed for publishing false news. If they report that the report was published, they get blamed for making it appear credible I'll also point out that if they don't report things they get accused of being involved in a cover up. What do you propose here exactly?
- TenOhms 10y agoCompare 'peegate' with 'pizzagate'. On the latter, the mainstream media wouldn't touch it with a 10 foot pole (rightly so), because so much was pure speculation from internet neckbeards and trolls (to use affectionate terms). With the former, we have the press doing the job of internet trolls, shoveling serious allegations with absolutely zero evidence given. Through a political lens it makes perfect sense, it's very sad, and I can't trust anything the main stream media tells me anymore. They've lost me forever unless there's a serious 'come to jesus' moment and they confess their bias and rectify it.