3 ms·
What is this nonsense? A domain iooks up to an IP address (and some other things). DNS does not and should not care about what protocols are going to be used wi
by dheera 10y ago
What is this nonsense? A domain iooks up to an IP address (and some other things). DNS does not and should not care about what protocols are going to be used with said IP address.
I can use an .onion domain for unencrypted Telnet as root with no password if I want. It's stupid but that's not something that should be restricted at a DNS level.
- erydo 10y agoAt first I agreed with you, but realized that my preferred solution was essentially what they recommended and just with different wording. My thought process was: - Absolutely, DNS resolvers should not care or have knowledge of the protocol that will be used to access that address. - What they *should* do is just say that normal DNS resolvers shouldn't ever resolve .onion addresses. - (And then Tor should include a special DNS resolver that does anyway.) - Oh, that's compatible with what they said. I think some of the confusion comes from their use of "applications".
- sp332 10y agoIt says the DNS lookup should not be performed.
- Ajedi32 10y agoThe problem is that > Tor should include a special DNS resolver that does anyway Would be pointless, given that the spec says: > Applications that do not implement the Tor protocol SHOULD generate an error upon the use of .onion and SHOULD NOT perform a DNS lookup. So according to this spec, even if you did implement a special DNS resolver, only TOR-aware applications would be able to use it, and that's pointless since TOR-aware applications can connect to `.onion` services without using DNS at all.