5 ms·
FWIW this came after a long long period of the DNSOP working group throwing hate and venom on this form of hithertofore non-normative DNS use cases. This was a
by rektide 10y ago
FWIW this came after a long long period of the DNSOP working group throwing hate and venom on this form of hithertofore non-normative DNS use cases. This was a very hot topic and it seemed like absolutely no progress was going to be made making this happen for a long time due to the DNSOPS wg.
I don't have good citations- would love to gather them again- but it was only after other IETF members started questioning the absurd rejectionist behavior of the DNSOP working group that this changed, and the .onion draft was allowed to get due status.
I can't think of any case in IETF history of a draft being so hotly denied and rejected. Very interesting story, look forward to someone telling it better than I.
- wereHamster 10y agoWho are the people in the DNSOP WG? Which companies do they work for? And why do these companies reject the RFC?
- nl 10y agoMuch of the time the people on IETF WGs have been on them for years through multiple companies. There are exceptions, but often this rejectionist-type behavior isn't because of some kind of corporate influence, it is because the new thing doesn't match what these people think should be done.
- mastax 10y ago> I don't have good citations- would love to gather them again Here's a good place to start for anyone interested: https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/search/?email_list=dnsop&q=onion&gbt=1&index=4dMYqpyFXWf7QlGMtTjL6ZLNK7I https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/search/?email_list=dnsop&q...
- chatmasta 10y agoMan, sometimes I wonder if in 20-30 years there will be anyone left who is this passionate about such seemingly obscure topics. The Internet owes much of its success to these people.
- rangibaby 10y agoOf course. In Japan for example if you can name a topic or activity, no matter how obscure, there will be an otaku (enthusiast) or even a club of otaku for it. What makes you think there will be less interest in obscure topics in the future?
- supergreg 10y agoAnd here in the West everything has a subreddit. I can only imagine the future holds even better, resilient ways for obscure topics to gather people like distributed forums and such.
- canndrew2016 10y agoAlso, they were originally trying to get several already-in-use psuedo-TLDs recognized including .onion, .i2p, .bit and .gns, but they had to compromise.
- Tepix 10y agoIs someone working on getting .bit officially recognized by the IETF?
- canndrew2016 10y agoNot that I know of now. Here's the original RFC that became the RFC which got .onion recognized http://www.potaroo.net/ietf/idref/draft-grothoff-iesg-special-use-p2p-names/ http://www.potaroo.net/ietf/idref/draft-grothoff-iesg-specia... They were trying to get .gns, .zkey, .onion, .exit, .i2p and .bit recognized.
- nerdponx 10y agoWhat is .bit?
- bnr 10y agohttps://bit.namecoin.org/ https://bit.namecoin.org/