4 ms·
We don't need neo-nazis on HN: http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21710866-1848-1939-history-pernicious-word-americas-alt-right-learns-speak-nazi http://www.
by acdha 10y ago
We don't need neo-nazis on HN:
http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21710866-1848-1939-history-pernicious-word-americas-alt-right-learns-speak-nazi http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21710866-1848-1939-hist...
- berry_sortoro 10y agoSo I am a Neo-Nazi for using a the word Lügenpresse for press the lies and lies over and over again? And of course you link another fake news article claiming this word has roots on Nazi Germany when in fact this is a lie, its roots are in fact from earlier. But why care and do some actual research when you can just read political correct MSM Lügenpresse? This guild by association BS does not work on people who can actually think for themselves. Because certain people in history used a word, does not mean everybody who uses it again is also part of this group/believe/mindset/... . But that of course how you political correct people tick. In your minds you create this tainted words nobody should dare to touch ever again because god beware someone evil used them brefore. Your creating a mind prison for yourselves its ridiculous! Is HN a save space for PCs? I will find out sooner then later I guess.
- skibble 10y ago'Are you a neo-Nazi?' No-one here knows, but you certainly sound like one. The swastika carries a very potent and toxic meaning today that it didn't until the last century or so. If you think symbolism and language are namby pamby liberal constructs with no inherent meaning, I'd encourage you to spray paint one on your house or have one tattooed on your forehead and see if the people you encounter as a result share your disdain for 'political correctness'. I doubt you are a neo-Nazi. But words have meaning, and while this may just be an abstract game of righteous keyboard warfare to you, perhaps if you have an issue with the objectivity or accuracy of the media it would be best to say that plainly. Code words and innuendo directed at other members of your clique won't convince anyone and may well offend people with a better grasp on history (though that was likely your intention).
- berry_sortoro 10y agoI sound like one for the use of a world in a modern completely different context then the Nazis did? In fact much of the modern world is very Fascist, and I am against that. But thanks for being the poster child for exactly of that mindset I meant. I like the word because I am for one German, and I agree with its general meaning in this modern age in regards to MSM. And I will continue to use it. The swastika is a very beautiful spiritual symbol used in India and all over the world. What are you trying to say? That its great how society tainted it to be never to be used again because some idiot used it for his sick crap in the past? Why use Autobahn then to drive cars on, Hitler build them they are pure evil you MUST NOT TOUCH EVER! You use the fact that most people will not get any other use then to display allegiance to nazis (at least in most places, no idea about India and other places like that TBH) as a argument? This is a the very way of thinking I hate. In fact it should be possible to use it (in steet art, on your house-wall, on your forehead ...). But people like to be slaves to their own minds, and they even like it. Its pathetic. Oh I you think I use it as a "Code Word" thats funny. Not at all but think what you like. And here I thought there would be some intelligent ppl on MH. Did you have a public crying thread around here when Hillary lost? lol (Not a Trump supporter BTW)
- openasocket 10y agoYou can tattoo a swastika on your forehead if you want. That's perfectly legal in the US. But I, and most people, will assume you're a neo-nazi. You can tell me and everyone you meet how that assumption is wrong, but that will be their initial impression regardless. Do with that information what you will.
- berry_sortoro 10y agoFor one I don't live in the US and I would have tremendous respect for anyone who would actually do this without being a nazi, trying to break the conditioning. A beautiful women with an nice artistic face tattoo should do it, that could work I guess. In Germany you need to be very crazy to do this, here you are legally forbidden to question anything about the Holocaust, I am not speaking of denial here, I speak of actually presenting any sort of evidence to a court. If you question anything about whats written in history books, lets say the number of Jews killed by the Nazis you are going to jail without a trail. You will be not allowed to submit anything to court. If you not blindly believe anything they tell you, your a criminal. You are not allowed to question anything about it at all. Now imagine how people react of you have a swastika on your head. Its probably illegal, I don't know but things are that crazy here. Swastikas were removed from video games where you actually fight the Nazis! People are crazy. What is called conservative in the US and is perfectly normal for you, is called far right here. The political mid here what you call radical left. So in Germany's PC think I might actually be a Nazi.
- acdha 10y agoSpeaking of doing research, you might find actually reading the link undercuts your attempt to claim fake news: the second paragraph, for example, makes it clear that the term predates Nazi Germany by almost a century before noting ‘Lügenpresse refers to any medium that does not reflect the user’s own worldview, and must therefore be propagated by a hated “Other”.’. The reason why I used “neo-Nazi” was that, again as noted in the article and many other sources, the term was avoided for years until various extremist groups started using it. Until Trump supporters started trying to normalize hatred for the media, I only saw it used by people who were also sharing anti-Semitic slurs and cartoons, racist memes, etc. I'm sure, of course, that you already know the negative implications and were just trying to get a reaction but that doesn't mean there's any value to dragging that particular mess into this thread. There are plenty of corners of the internet where you can scratch that particular itch without polluting a discussion about a website enabling a security feature.