3 ms·
So where is the traction proof for a "Proven market need" for self driving cars? Whenever we discuss new ventures on HN, the number one thing repeated is the Y
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
So where is the traction proof for a "Proven market need" for self driving cars?
Whenever we discuss new ventures on HN, the number one thing repeated is the YC mantra "Make something that people want." Yet I don't see the "solves a concrete problem that people are looking for solutions now for."
You can certainly make the case based on long range conjecture that there would be big benefits: lower fatalities, more free time, less congestion etc... but those are all projections assuming very high adoption.
However that whole "We need this now" attitude of making a winning product seems devoid - especially for the 90% of the potential users who would need to adopt them.
I personally think that these types of technologies don't have the same kind of demand that you'd look for in a typical breakthrough startup, but that technologists like us the HN crowd basically push hard enough to make them a reality.
I ask this because as someone who is working on a frontier technology (Augmented Reality) there are always a million questions around traction and user demand. Nobody ever wants to hear "we're going to create the market" yet it seems like that's exactly what we're doing with self driving cars.
edit: It's also possible that "startups" are not the right organizational structure to try and launch moonshot or frontier type technologies to the mainstream. So the same rules don't apply.
- ghaff 10y agoReally? Even if you limit self-driving to "I can kick back and watch TV on my highway commute" that seems as if it's an automobile feature that people would pay a non-trivial premium for. And, perhaps more importantly, would choose Brand X with the feature over Brand Y without it. There's a big market for convenience features in cars. (If you're talking the potentially many decades off roboUber, I don't necessarily disagree.)
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoIf you're talking the potentially many decades off roboUber, I don't necessarily disagree. I mean that's the whole selling point...and it would basically take that level 5 ability (as demonstrated in many articles and studies) to give you the "I can kick back and watch TV on my highway commute" ability. Hell you can install an in-dash DVD player now, but that's not the vision of self driving cars.
- ghaff 10y agoIt may be the main selling point for the urban "no one will own cars" crowd but, yes, they're way optimistic on timeframes anyway. Contra something I read recently, yes, kids being born this year will need to learn to drive. As I said, there's a huge market for incremental convenience and safety in a relatively short timeframe. But, yes, I'm more inclined to put my money on Volvo and Ford in that game than Google. ADDED: Level 3 autonomy doesn't require full attention in specific scenarios so it seems as if L3 would allow you to watch a movie on the highway.
- caf 10y agoParticularly since you'd presume that the "attention" alert would also stop the entertainment system.
- escape_goat 10y agoI don't have any proof that a market exists for these cars right now, but I can make up a story that suggests that a real market is indeed at play. There's a proven market need for that entire field of technology in general, the market of "doing things that were never before humanly possible while making billions of dollars in profit along the way". A self-driving car is a plausibly viable product, in that a person can imagine that it would provide him or her with personal safety, convenience, relief from effort, and extra leisure/work time. By itself, it could have a significant lifestyle effect both in terms of commuting and travel. However, even if it were not especially economically viable by itself, it would serve as a highly useful prototype and legislative precedent for the rather more dangerous and less sympathetic self-driving truck. The self-driving truck has advantages over the operated truck that go far beyond the savings in wages when all the truck drivers lose their jobs. It can operate continually and consistently, with lower maintenance costs; it can be prepositioned or rerouted at a moment's notice; it can integrate efficiently with other aspects of an partially automated logistics chain. It will create new value. In turn, it will serve as a prototype for other motile robotics technologies required by a fully automated logistics chain, all of which - taken together - will be a crucial step towards the full automation of the means of production. It is plausible that the major automotive manufacturers are more than happy to treat the self-driving car as a loss-leader. This is just a story I made up, rather than an authoritative or informed opinion, but I believe that it's fairly typical of the "imaginative futurist" version of the case for self-driving cars.