3 ms·
> Forbes is in fact refusing to serve him content Are they? A Google referrer gets you the content of the article at most, and at least it gets you some JavaS
by shakna 10y ago
> Forbes is in fact refusing to serve him content
Are they?
A Google referrer gets you the content of the article at most, and at least it gets you some JavaScript. Which is executed client-side.
Forbes serves up code, which the client should be able to parse, render and execute in any way they see fit, as it was served to their machine upon a simple GET request.
The client is under no obligation to behave well, in a programmatic sense, because it is just handed markup and source code, with an expectation of parsing and rendering it in a way fit for the client's user, otherwise you may as well ban screen reader's for doing things in unexpected ways.
> ... distribute it on his own
We both agree here that it would be bad ethics to do this.
- hsod 10y agoI see your point, but I don't agree with it. I think it leans far too heavily on the specific technical details of the web while remaining blind to the higher level reality of the situation. Put another way, I don't believe the specifics of the way the web operates serve as a solid foundation for an ethical principle. Far better, I think, to look at the people involved and focus on treating them fairly and honestly, abstracting away the medium of communication as an implementation detail.
- shakna 10y agoWhilst people and businesses matter, if you ignore how they do something entirely, it does become purely ethical. I use an adblocker only for malware protection, and pay many of the businesses I use online. But I will always defend someone's right to use the content as they were given it. If you give away data, don't be confused if someone uses it in a different way. Forbes appears to be finding a happy medium, or on their way. Such as disabling error logging caused by adblocking so that the user can have a decent experience. Edit: And I must say, despite our differing opinions, this has been an extremely pleasant exchange