4 ms·
I don't know if I agree with their arguments, but people have argued that people should be able to sell kidneys. Currently, this is illegal - people end up for
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
I don't know if I agree with their arguments, but people have argued that people should be able to sell kidneys.
Currently, this is illegal - people end up forming "donation chains" to spread the availability of organs.
- tptacek 10y agoOf course, there are coherent arguments for this. Among other things, it makes organs more available to recipients. But then where do you draw the line from there? If the principle is "my body my rules", why not sell both kidneys?
- joering2 10y agoWhy not? You stupid to sell both kidneys you die. How is that your problem?? If I have a need to help other people to the extend that it will kill me, let it be!
- tptacek 10y agoThen, should people be allowed to accept money to "perform" in snuff films? Or is it only OK to sell ones life if there's some material net benefit to other people that results from it?
- clavalle 10y agoI think people should be able to sell their organs, too /if/ they are perfectly free to make that choice and in no way coerced, actively or passively, to do so. But, in a world where one can sell their organs, would we refuse public assistance to people who still have both of their kidneys? Would we say to the poor "Why are you asking for help? You have $50,000 buried in your back! Come back when you are truly desperate."