7 ms·
Why has law enforcement suddenly become allergic to warrants? Warrants used to be a rather boring, but important, process that police had to fulfil to show that
by Someone1234 10y ago
Why has law enforcement suddenly become allergic to warrants? Warrants used to be a rather boring, but important, process that police had to fulfil to show that they had even a very flimsy case.
Now it seems like law enforcement and politicians who serve their whims are outright pushing to remove the warrant requirements from as much as possible. But why now? Warrants aren't new and the landscape hasn't changed that much, why are law enforcement suddenly pushing so hard on this?
Is this just a general theme on the broader problem of police oversight (or lack thereof)? This is one of the few areas of actual oversight left (judicial) so they're trying to remove that too.
- jstanley 10y agoThe landscape has changed hugely since 50 years ago. Individuals now have a lot more power than ever before thanks to the proliferation of technology, and individuals who want to subvert the aims of the state have a greater chance of doing so than ever. The state is beginning to recognise this and is taking steps to try to claw back some power.
- btilly 10y agoThe state is beginning to recognise this and is taking steps to try to claw back some power. My perception is opposite. Over the last 20 years we have gone from a fairly free country to what feels like a police state with the most effective surveillance in history. Are you actually familiar with, for example, the extent of Snowden's revelations? What an erosion of liberty the Patriot act is? Or how unusual it used to be to see armed security guards in random office buildings?
- jstanley 10y agoYes. These measures are being taken because individuals are getting more powerful. In the long run, I don't think the state is going to succeed, but it will be an arms race for a while.
- btilly 10y agoCan you offer evidence for your theory? My theory is that the state took advantage of the combination of panic over terrorism and falling costs of data storage to put their dreams into action. The threat that they purport to be protecting against isn't real. The threat that the state poses, sadly, is. As evidence I can point to the fact that dramatic increases of power increased after 9/11. Much of which was spent in security theater and clear power grabs with proven ineffectiveness. (cough TSA *cough) Anyone who was around in tech knows about the dramatic drop in costs for data storage, and knows how it has driven big data in general.
- gknoy 10y agoBoth your comments and the GP's ring true for me. - Individuals can communicate in secrecy, thanks to encryption and the internet, much more easily than before. This means that wiretapping as we used to know it is nearly impossible for some categories of conversations. - Surveillance is nearly omnipresent, partly as a way to combat the above. I don't like the erosions of liberty that you mention, or the militarization of police, but I can see why some of the things we take for granted (instant secret communications, encrypted volumes, thumb drives that can be hidden) and consider to be valuable can also frustrate law enforcement doing what we have told them is their mandate (catch bad actors).
- theobon 10y agoCan you expand on your comment that individuals have a lot more power? My admittedly anecdotal evidence shows that individuals are feeling more impotent with voices washed out in a wave a noise and an inability to affect anything.
- JabavuAdams 10y agoThat may be true for the masses, but look at the information resources that are out there for the technically inclined.
- evgen 10y agoTry to explain what "voice" your parents or grandparents had in an age where media consisted of a handful of radio/TV/newspaper establishments controlled by powerful vested interests. Not only was your voice non-existent, but you had no tools available to magnify your voice. Add in the fact that information with which you might build a coherent argument was siloed and generally unavailable, that you had limited resources to gain any sort of expertise outside of your job, and individual "power" in previous ages appears more like the mirage of nostalgia than anything else. This, of course, is assuming that you are a white male. If not then you had no individual power at all and were severely limited just in terms of your individual autonomy.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Try to explain what "voice" your parents or grandparents had in an age where media consisted of a handful of radio/TV/newspaper establishments controlled by powerful vested interests. Back before there was social media and other online "new media" (which , together with the remaining "old media", is concentrated in fewer and larger vested interests than the media was a generation or two ago) people shared ideas person to person (the term "viral" that's been adopted in social media actually drew on a use that referred to non-media person-to-person information transmittal before the explosion of "new media"). People outside of the media establishment had voices before modern "new media".
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 1_2__3 10y agoYou are a horrific threat to democracy.
- randcraw 10y agoI've forgotten the precise number, but something like 75% of 'convictions' currently arise from plea bargains and not trials. As such, these overreach practices usually escape judicial review, and especially so if the punishment is light (a fine but no jail time). The only cure for this practice is for a civil rights defense resource like ACLU or EFF to invite those prosecuted to take the case to trial and then appeal verdicts until the practice receives the official rebuff it so richly deserves.
- abecedarius 10y ago"97 percent of federal cases and 94 percent of state cases end in plea bargains" -- http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/23/us/stronger-hand-for-judges-after-rulings-on-plea-deals.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/23/us/stronger-hand-for-judge... which does not seem to give a source.
- fennecfoxen 10y agoStill better than Japan, where 97% of cases end in a confession. http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21679472-suspects-japanese-police-cells-are-far-too-vulnerable-abuse-forced-confess http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21679472-suspects-japa... And the prisons are clean, well lit, dehumanizing psychological torture chambers. http://www.economist.com/news/asia/21679483-why-you-might-prefer-bangkok-jail-one-chiba-silent-screams http://www.economist.com/news/asia/21679483-why-you-might-pr...
- ue_ 10y agoI have known about this for a while, and it's so horrible. I've wanted to work in Japan for a while.
- Zancarius 10y agoOne of the times I was on jury duty, we sat in the pool room for about 3 hours during which each of the 7 trials scheduled on that day fell through and ended in a plea bargain. We were dismissed before noon after a brief explanation. Of course, this is just a single data point, and take it as you will. It only happened once during my service, but it did happen. As such, I'd find your 75% figure believable. This was a local district court, and I guarantee nearly all of those were drug-related charges.
- tn13 10y agoPartly because now everyone has strong incentives to put random people in jail. 1. Politicians can ensure voters are perpetually scared of "increasing crime" when in reality USA is safer than ever. 2. Narcissist DAs to feel good about themselves. 3. Cops to justify their existence and demand more resources 4. Prison Industrial Complex. Minimum mandatory play a big role. Imagine your laptop which was given to repair miraculously had a porn clip where it may be argued that the model was 17 year old. Would your rather spend 16 years in jail and in sex offenders registry or will you take the plea bargain where you spend 6 months in jail ?
- Nelson69 10y agoHow would a warrant work in this case? BestBuy reports that they found child porn, but proceeds to give the computer back to the owner? Is that legal or are they trafficking? Meanwhile the FBI goes and requests a warrant based upon what they heard from BestBuy? That seems almost more slippery to me, does the FBI just need to "hear something" from somebody to get a warrant to look around? Or is it even possible for them to get a warrant in a case like this, save for BestBuy involving them like they do? This seems like the step that causes a warrant to be issued for more stuff. How I'd imagine it goes: 1) BestBuy worker finds child porn while doing normal work. 2) BestBuy worker does "extra work" to report child porn to FBI and does not return the machine, he files some paperwork, maybe makes a full backup, etc.. 3) BestBuy employee signs a deposition, BestBuy hands machine over to FBI with owner's information 4) BestBuy or BestBuy employee gets some money (I'd think BestBuy would want their cut but that's a detail, maybe they're cool to their people in that way) for doing "extra work" and reporting crime. 5) FBI and federal prosecutors look at evidence, seek warrant for other evidence, start planning case. Perhaps said warrant makes a big case or identifies nothing else. 6) BestBuy worker may potentially be called to testify. Sadly at the end of the day $500 isn't going to pay much for a personal lawyer and I think it would be ill-advised to show up to court in any capacity in a federal case without one. ...