3 ms·
I think it comes down to whether these people are acting on their own initiative or whether they're being told to do this stuff beforehand. To take your electr
by mikeash 10y ago
I think it comes down to whether these people are acting on their own initiative or whether they're being told to do this stuff beforehand.
To take your electrician example, I have no problem with the scenario you present. Where I'd have a problem is if the police set up a program to recruit electricians and ask them to keep an eye out for illegal activities, and promised them payment if they find stuff.
Protections against illegal searches can't be this easy to work around, otherwise what would be the point of having them? If this was sufficient to satisfy the 4th Amendment, then any time the police wanted to search a house, all they'd have to do is, say, contact a local utility and have one of their employees pretend to check the property and report back all the illegal stuff they saw. (And I'm sure someone will post a link to a story about police doing exactly that.)
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> And I'm sure someone will post a link to a story about police doing exactly that. I'm pretty sure it's been done, yes (though I don't have a case that I can cite). What's more interesting to me, though, is that it's not done all the time. Why isn't it? I suspect because the courts take a dim view of this kind of stunt (again, I don't have a case to cite). But in the current climate, if this would pass muster with the courts, wouldn't the police do it frequently? Frequently enough that we'd hear about it somewhat regularly?