3 ms·
I've long been suspecting that there is something weird going on at reddit. Frequently we'll post something and see it get nuked. Then a few days later one of a
by KirinDave 17y ago
I've long been suspecting that there is something weird going on at reddit. Frequently we'll post something and see it get nuked. Then a few days later one of a few familiar names posts it and suddenly it does very well, usually with a pass through another blog as opposed to a direct link.
I wonder if that entire system is silently rigged to control traffic.
- bd 17y agoNo need for rigging the system, few simple rules and many individual actions can produce complex behaviors. New queue on reddit moves very fast - currently the oldest item is just about 7 minutes old. It's very easy to go unnoticed by target audience (people who would upvote the submission) in such short time window. Multiple submissions mean post has higher chance to get noticed. Eventual downvotes come from people who want to decrease competition for their own submissions, giving them extra few minutes in new queue. Also people may check submission queues of familiar users because they like their submissions, thus increasing chances of such submissions being noticed. Similar thing already started to happen here on HN. Even with new queue being much longer (at about 1 hour) there are multiplicities. Many times the same post (though not necessarily the same url) gets submitted multiple times and only later submissions get promoted to the frontpage. Well, sometimes it even happens that in a span of few hours/days the same story appears on frontpage several times, with completely disjoint set of commenters not being aware of earlier discussions.
- KirinDave 17y agoI fear the flag button may become the new downbote tool for people with flawed metrics for success.
- jwegan 17y agoIf your posts stay at 1 upvote then you've probably been blocked by the spam filter. If that is the case you just need to PM a moderator to take a look at the post and then will unblock it. It won't help for that posts, but the spam filter should learn from it and not block your future posts.
- KirinDave 17y agoThis isn't just a sample size of KirinDave, this is a common theme for many people I know. If we are all caught by a spam filter, then Reddit is doing something very wrong.
- blhack 17y agoReddit's spam filter is completely and totally broken (or at least was about a month ago). The moderators effectively get to pick and choose what stories even hit the queue. I had a user there (same handle as here) that had something like 3000 link karma and something in the tens of thousands of comment karma. Every story I posted would get flagged as "spam", meaning I had to message a moderator. Typically, the responses I would get would be things like "sorry, I don't really like the article. Post it somewhere else.". Granted, these were typically opinion articles that I had written, so I could understand where they were coming from to a small degree. The problem with this was that the ones that did get accepted usually made the front page. Don't get me wrong, I still use reddit to a degree, but it isn't really a technology site anymore. People will say things like "subscribe to better subreddits!", and I do, but none of them really see much traffic. A lot of times, I'll load the page and it will say "there is nothing here". The pics section has some funny things (although the majority of them seem to be tagged with 4gifs.com, which I assume means they all came from 4chan), and so does the "ask" section. There is still some entertainment value to the site, but it isn't really a list of democratically chosen articles anymore.
- KirinDave 17y agoYou could have summed this up by saying, "Reddit is fundamentally broken, at a technology level. Move along." ;)