11 ms·
"If it’s true that algorithms are statistically better than drivers then we shouldn’t let people to drive. But there are still a lot of people that love to driv
by gambiting 10y ago
"If it’s true that algorithms are statistically better than drivers then we shouldn’t let people to drive. But there are still a lot of people that love to drive. This can be a fun recreational activity but we just don’t need those people on the road."
I don't know who "we" is in that sentence, but thanks for making the decision for everyone. "we" as a society also absolutely don't need smokers, drinkers and people who engage in extreme sports - but fortunately, we are not robots, and we allow activities which do not have any utility for the "we" of society.
- nmbdesign 10y agoDamn, don't you think "we" as a society should eliminate the negative effects/activities? since aside of not having any utility it may bring negative outcomes..
- gambiting 10y agoThe problem is, that "negative effect/activity" is not an objective thing. To me, drinking(alcohol) is a pointless activity, with literally no upside. It costs money, doesn't feel good, I don't see the social aspect of it, and the danger it poses to people is well documented - it's a "negative" for society in my book. But, at the same time, I am fully happy to acknowledge that there are people who enjoy it, who like to party, and I would never say that drinking should be banned. I know a few people who treat driving like I treat drinking - they see it as boring, without any benefit, with negative consequences well documented and they clearly think that society would be better off without it. They think that the day that manual drivers are banned can't come soon enough. As mentioned above - we are not robots. Not everyone enjoys the same things. And that's great.
- nmbdesign 10y agoI don't think comparing drinking to driving is a good idea, think of drunk driving, it's illegal. Why? Because it kills people it brings negative experiences such a death on a scale, just drinking at the bar doesn't cause this, right? The same thing with driving in an autonomous environment, if it causes rapid increase in killings - it should be illegal in the same way as drunk driving. Don't you think so?
- sharemywin 10y agoso guns should be banned? large knives? red meat because all the methane?
- nmbdesign 10y agoPlease read my comment above, I'm not saying the TOOL or an object should be banned but a COMBINATION of a USE should be banned. And yes, the use large knives in public places where there is a risk of killing people should be banned, is there any objection to this?
- FrancoDiaz 10y agoYes, there is objection to that. There's plenty of legitimate reasons to have a large knife in a public place..obviously. There's only a risk of killing people unless you're ISIS or a psychopath. Do we ban everything because of a few assholes? Yes, we do a lot of the time, and that's pretty sad.
- gambiting 10y agoNo, actually I think that long time before autonomous cars are common, or anyone even thinks about banning manual cars, vast majority of cars on the market will be already equipped with systems preventing accidents. There will be no reason to ban manual cars, because manual cars will be nearly impossible to crash, unless you specifically want to crash(and I bet you will be able to do that in an autonomous cars too since I can't imagine it won't have some sort of manual override). Also, just to address your last point - why would manual driving cause increase in killings? In the worst possible case, it would stay at the same level as now,no? In fact, it's hard to argue that it won't get better, because autonomous cars will avoid dangerous situations caused by manual drivers better than humans would. In other words - in increasingly autonomous environment, the risk factor of manual drivers will go down, not up.
- lg 10y agoif self-driving cars will be as safe as people say, manual driving should have the same legal status as drunk driving due to the unnecessary danger it creates.
- nmbdesign 10y agoyes! thanks for making this point in a much clear way than my discussion in another comment thread haha
- knz 10y agoIt's a false comparison though. 1) Society tolerates a small amount of alcohol for most drivers. 2) Driving while drunk impairs your physical and mental ability to drive safely and only gets worse as you drink more. Obviously a manual driver has slower reaction times than an autonomous system but they are within a level that society tolerates and far better than someone who is drunk. There are also risks with autonomous vehicles - the potential for equipment/sensor failure, software being unable to adequately handle bad weather, the potential for exploitation by hackers etc. I'm currently in the process of buying a new vehicle and have been test driving vehicles with various sensors designed to prevent accidents (specifically the Subaru eyesight system). One of my first thoughts was that it would be easy to become reliant on the technology and have a serious accident when a sensor fails (particularly for blind spot detection). I'm still likely going to buy a vehicle with that functionality but am not sure how much I will trust it.
- lg 10y ago> they are within a level that society tolerates For now, because there are no alternatives so we've all gotten used to ~31,000 annual US motor vehicle deaths. If self-driving tech drastically cuts down on that, society's tolerance will change.
- knz 10y agoHow many of those are attributable to factors that could be mitigated through augmented systems (a cap on how fast a vehicle could travel, collision avoidance systems, HUD's etc) though? Those could probably be implemented much more easily and affordably. To me the appeal of truly autonomous vehicles (in additional to some safety improvements) is being able to reclaim my commute time.
- SFjulie1 10y agoWell, autonomous car are better than most drivers: violation of insecure/nonprudential behaviour are systematically under-enforced. The freedom to scare bikes and pedestrians who have had the right to move freely in cities for centuries is a given. The weight of car lobbying creating the jay walking crime have resulted in a culture of road violence turned to the systematic acceptation of behaviour that would over-wise be considered psychopathic asocial. And cars are killing/injuring more citizen worldwide than guns and terrorisms: 35K deaths in 2016 in USA alone for instance. However why are autonomous cars more secure? Spoiler alert of the secret recipe for progress: because they respect security distance, right priority, stop when pedestrian are engaged on a crossing. Self driving cars don't behave like assholes! However I see a problem with autonomous car: their sensors can trigger false positive or negative. Behaving correctly in respect to the other users on the road would cost lest to the collectivity and bring more peace. But, it would mean a political decision, a loss of business for car manufacturer and software industry, it would mean ruling that having money to buy a car don't give you special privileges in the public space. This would mean that economy should not rule our life. Only left leaning social-liberals would go for this. And given who people are voting for recently in occident, we at best head towards a status quo to avoid pissing the car drivers, or hidden subsidies to industry by forcing users to have self driving cars under the claim it will save life. The giving up on freedom for security. Ideally, still, not tolerating and sanctioning heavily the violent behaviours could be the right move. Car accidents when injuries are resulting from a non respect of a secure/prudential behaviour should be prosecuted as a criminal intention. And car/software manufacturers should also be held accountable under the same rule of their engineering bugs not solved with due diligence as soon as they are revealed.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoDriving 100 mph is also a fun recreational activity that's mostly banned because it's dangerous. If you want to drive 100mph, you need to either go to a track or go to the Autobahn. In the future, I imagine that manually driving will be similarly constrained.
- FrancoDiaz 10y agoIf you want to drive 100mph, you need to either go to a track or go to the Autobahn. Obviously you don't have to go to those places.
- 3chelon 10y agoOnce the technology is good enough, there is no theoretical reason for a speed limit. I'm looking forward to sitting in the auto-lane cutting code at 200mph while the petrol-heads are doing a thrilling 70 in the manual lane beside me!
- brokenmachine 10y agoI know you're joking but there is still a reason for a speed limit. Tyres/brakes/everything are more likely to fail the faster you go, and unknowns like animals coming onto the road and weather will always be a thing.
- olalonde 10y ago"Smoking, drinking and extreme sports" are not great comparisons because they only put yourself at risk (for the most part). Driving, on the other hand, can endanger other people's life on the road.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoSecond hand smoking puts others in risk too.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThat's why some places have legislation for this. For instance, in Poland it's illegal to smoke in public transit stops, and in restaurants you can only smoke in designated smoking areas, etc.
- wtbob 10y ago> Second hand smoking puts others in risk too. No, no it does not. So-called 'second-hand smoke' (a genius marketing term for smoke) is no more harmful than any other smoke. It is, however, a wonderful excuse for the sort of people who like controlling other people to … control other people.
- gambiting 10y ago>>So-called 'second-hand smoke' (a genius marketing term for smoke) is no more harmful than any other smoke I've read this sentence literally a dozen times and I still don't understand how it relates to the point we made about second-hand smoke being bad - you are trying to make a point about incorrect naming, to maybe detract from the main point?. Smoke harms other people. If you smoke, you harm other people, who get in the way of your smoke. Here, is that easier to process?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> So-called 'second-hand smoke' [...] is no more harmful than any other smoke. While true (in fact, it's less harmful than first-hand cigarette smoke, which is what the "second hand" is distinguishing it from) that doesn't contradict the fact that it puts others at risk. Smoke (whether cigarette smoke or otherwise) is a fairly significant health hazard that you don't want spend lots of time exposed to.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoThere are kinds of driving that are fun and already not allowed on the road. For example, racing, or rallying, or just going very very fast. There are private tracks where you can pay to go and do that. Or sometimes they close the public roads and put up crash barriers for a big race. But they don't let you mix up your desire to go 200 MPH with regular commuter traffic.
- gambiting 10y agoI never said anything about driving fast. I actually really enjoy my 45-60 minute commute to work, because controlling a car is just cool - and I get to listen to my favourite podcasts/music while I drive. It gives me a sense of satisfaction and of something well done when I reach my destination. Getting the car in the right gear, hearing the engine thrum - you don't need to be doing 100mph to enjoy that. But again, I don't want to be convincing anybody that they should love cars, that's not my point.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAgain, I think everyone understands the cool factor here. The point is, fun should not be used to determine what is or isn't allowed on public, shared infrastructure, especially if it causes danger to other people.
- FrancoDiaz 10y agoAnd banning self-driving also is a convenient way for totalitarians to control the movement of the population. Of course we never hear about that around here.
- dclowd9901 10y agoAnd aliens could come from space and take over our planet. What's your point?
- FrancoDiaz 10y agoYou know my point, you just don't like it. It's far from a stretch of the imagination to see a future where the government essentially has a kill-switch for most roads.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt already has - as long as police and military still follows orders, they can blockade any road or set of roads at will, very quickly.
- wtbob 10y agoOf course, a vehicle can still go around those road blocks, currently — a car _can_ drive across grass or dirt, just not terribly well. That's very different from an area-denial killswitch.
- dclowd9901 10y agoIt's not about not liking it. It's simply infeasible to think in this day and age a totalitarian regime would ever gain traction in the United States.
- dragonwriter 10y agoOne of the reasons it is plausible is that so many people disregard the risk because they see it as implausible.
- CaptSpify 10y agoBut driving on non-closed roads means you are interacting with people around you. Smoking, drinking, extreme-sports don't necessitate putting others at risk.
- gambiting 10y agoSecond hand smoke harms people. A lot of household violence is fueled by alcohol. Then of course we are all affected by cost of treatment of smokers/alcoholics/people harmed in sporting incidents. Don't know how the numbers compare to driving, but the point is that the author of the article maybe shouldn't authoritatively say what "we" need or don't need.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> Second hand smoke harms people. If you blow smoke in people's faces, you are an ass. I say this as someone who sometimes smokes. > A lot of household violence is fueled by alcohol. But alcohol isn't the cause of this. I don't care why you are violent at home, but your an ass if you are. These are situations where people are bringing in others on their activity unnecessarily. It's still apples to oranges IMO
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> Second hand smoke harms people. That's why many places in the world use regulation to ban smoking in areas where people gather (like bus stops, restaurants). > A lot of household violence is fueled by alcohol. Hence, again, lots of regulation, also lots of social programs aimed at mitigating the harm caused by alcohol. You may argue whether too much or too little is done in each of those cases, but the problems are recognized and addressed.