4 ms·
This is interesting: > The search of Rettenmaier’s hard drive has a further wrinkle. The image was located on “unallocated space,” which is where deleted items
by koolba 10y ago
This is interesting:
> The search of Rettenmaier’s hard drive has a further wrinkle. The image was located on “unallocated space,” which is where deleted items reside on a computer until they are overwritten when the space is needed. Unallocated space is not easily accessed — it requires special forensic software.
> Prosecutors said that the Geek Squad technician who searched the unallocated space was merely trying to recover all the data Rettenmaier had asked to be restored. Riddet argued that the technician was going beyond the regular search to deleted material to find evidence the FBI might want.
It's not difficult to recreate files that have been deleted but not fully wiped from the disk. But it's also not trivial. If the Best Buy techs are finding things in those regions of the disk then that means they're explicitly looking at what's there. It's not just a matter of, "Hey the desktop wallpaper of this guy's laptop is kiddie porn, I should report this!", these guys are actively searching people's computers on behalf of the Feds.
- anilgulecha 10y ago> Prosecutors said that the Geek Squad technician who searched the unallocated space was merely trying to recover all the data Rettenmaier had asked to be restored Depends on what was asked to be recovered, but I'm guessing it's just a brute-force 'undelete' type program that was run, which usually lists all scourable/recoverable nodes from the "free" space. In this scenario, there is no difference between what was asked to be restored, and was found.. since the undelete types of programs always list all found files, and ask you to pick which to restore. So if some file-names there were suspicious, that's not different from the "I saw a CP wallpaper". Conjecture, of course. We do not know the exact communication.
- throwaway729 10y agoThis was my thought originally, but then I read the article. I no longer believe this is what happened. Official Best Buy policy is exactly as you state -- we don't perform an invasive search for illegal content, but if we find it in the course of normal operations, we will report it. Official Best Buy policy is that individual employees will not accept payments from the FBI. But, one supervisor did accept payments from the FBI. That same supervisor remained in contact with the FBI for years. And that same supervisor lied under oath about receiving those payments. He was in regular contact with the FBI, accepted regular payments from the FBI, and -- what's more -- felt the need to lie about that relationship. I think it's extremely likely that he was having those he supervised perform searches that would not otherwise have been performed has he not received payment from the FBI. That's probably the factual question that this case will boil down to -- would this material have been uncovered if a different supervisor, following all of Best Buy's policies, had been in charge that day?
- randcraw 10y agoAnd now that the supervisor's paid service to the FBI has been revealed, will all past convictions based on his efforts (and the court and defense costs of those found not guilty) be subject to overturn/redress as unlawful violations of search? They should be, but I doubt it'll happen.
- fjdlwlv 10y agoShouldn't it boil down to fruit of the poisonous tree, and the illegally obtained evidence is inadmissible regardless of how it could have been parallel constructed?
- throwaway729 10y agoMy suggestion is that this question boils down to the one that I identified. If the search was executed only because the supervisor was effectively acting on behalf of the FBI, then the evidence was probably illegally obtained. Prosecution will argue that the search would've happened and been reported regardless of the supervisor's relationship to the FBI. So that the relationship, while perhaps shady, actually had zero bearing on the events that took place. The judge will have to decide which of those is more likely to be true. The conduct of the supervisor and the FBI is probably going to be a huge PITA for the prosecutor to explain away.
- ikeboy 10y agoHe sent his hard drive in to recover data, it's entirely plausible that they ran a scan of unallocated space, got a bunch of files, then looked at them to check if they were corrupted (very often recovered files only have a tiny bit of the original file), and found they were corrupted in a very different way.
- paco3346 10y agoThis still sounds like stumbling upon to me. Have you ever used that kind of recovery software? Typically it ignores filesystem indexes and searches the whole disk for content. If the customer was asking for data to be restored the tech was inherently having to search the while disk.
- finid 10y agothese guys are actively searching people's computers on behalf of the Feds. Seems so, and $500 is a good incentive for a Geek Squad worker.
- roel_v 10y agoThey are actively searching people's computers because that's exactly what the customer is asking them to do. This is how 'undelete' software works - you scan all sectors, take everything that looks like it might at some point have been part of an operational filesystem, then re-assemble sectors back into files. You then have to check if those files are actually what the algorithm thought they were. I can somewhat understand that a defense lawyer tries to muddle the waters to get his client off (as is done in the OP), but the comments on here claiming that this is somehow unusual or going beyond normal data recovery work leave me slapping my forehead.
- gist 10y agoStatistically, and with $500 as a reward, it seems plausible that a technician from time to time might plant something to collect the bounty. I would wonder what the 'chain of custody' is and/or the specific techniques used that would prove this was not possible. After all from what I read they aren't even looking for corroborating evidence just parts of files w/o knowledge of how they even got there.
- fjdlwlv 10y agoIt's a valid concern, but on the cases I have seen, convictions don't come from one piece of evidence, the initial evidence leads to far more. But even a dead end investigation (from a mistaken or false pretenses) can be a large burden on the accused
- samfisher83 10y agoIf the hard drive is corrupt and FAT tables/inodes are screwed up you would just try to recover as many files as you can in which case you would look at the raw data for files instead of where the files where.
- droithomme 10y agoNot only that but there can remnants of hundreds of thousands if not millions of deleted temp, cache and other files on the typical computer, quite a few which is stuff like temporarily downloaded cache files from sections of web pages a user didn't scroll to, didn't see, and wasn't aware of. These technicians obviously didn't review all the unallocated space and determine what was there. It's pretty clear they had a set of patterns they were looking for representing known illegal content, and some kind of automated software that scans the unallocated space looking for that content.
- Fuxy 10y agoThere is also the fact that a lot of junk can end up in unallocated space. For instance images and resources cached by Firefox while in use tend to end up on the HDD. If you browse around porn sites you know sometime some of the thumbnails etc do look like CP from time to time. Now should that cached resource from a random website be considered evidence of CP? Or what if it's a photo of your own family and it is intimate but not in a CP kind of way. I've hard of many cases where a random family photo was reported as CP.
- fencepost 10y agoAs far as what sort of steps would be usual for recovery, a lot of it would depend on the nature of the drive failure. If the drive is damaged enough that directory information and the MFT are missing, there are certainly situations in which it would make sense to run TestDisk and PhotoRec, which are freely available and widely included in data recovery builds. It's been a long time since I needed to use PhotoRec (and I've learned a lot more since), but my recollection from the time is that it basically goes chugging through the disk looking for sectors that contain the beginning of a recognized file format, then starts pulling that off until it reaches an end or another file beginning operating on the hope that at least some files will have been stored contiguously on the drive. By the time you get to PhotoRec there's a good chance you've given up on just being able to get back to regular filesystem access. As a side note for anyone contemplating drive recovery without pro tools, the ABSOLUTE FIRST thing to do is image the drive into a file (probably with ddrescue). NEVER use these tools on the original drive if there's data on there that you value, and if there's data that you REALLY value, consider sending it to a professional that's also able to do a clean-room evaluation (which usually won't be required). Some places are absurdly expensive, but a lot of recoveries will only cost a few hundred dollars. "Yep, all your data's still in the drive. After your freezing/spinning/whacking recovery efforts, most of it's in that fine grey dust in the filter."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]