3 ms·
they are too easy to press accidentally The solution is to have user interfaces that are forgiving and don't punish the user for making a mistake.
by onion2k 10y ago
they are too easy to press accidentally
The solution is to have user interfaces that are forgiving and don't punish the user for making a mistake.
- croon 10y ago>The solution is to have user interfaces that are forgiving and don't punish the user for making a mistake. Meaning ignoring input? Which in turn would suggest scrapping features to mitigate mistakes. Which would mean not a professional tool. I'm not arguing with your statement on its own, but I highly disagree in this context. In any professional tool I use, I want a 1:1 representation of _EVERYTHING_ I do. The thought of a tool treating me like an idiot (which I am) but correcting me (according to ITS OWN LOGIC) and not letting me learn (which I can) is making me furious to even consider.
- coldpie 10y agoNo, the solution is to JUST USE BUTTONS.
- onion2k 10y agoPeople[1] often press the wrong button even when they're physical buttons. [1] Me.
- freehunter 10y agoUgh, my car has real buttons for changing the stations on the radio, but it's a + type of button. Far too often I hit "up" to change stations up, but no, changing stations up is "right". Pushing the up button changes the genre of stations for the satellite radio. And you'd think I would get used to that, but on the steering wheel controls, the up arrow changes the station up. Buttons are better than touch, but I still have to fiddle with poorly laid-out buttons.
- Piskvorrr 10y agoA solution for an artificially invented problem. Right. ("Have forgiving interfaces" is good advice, but completely orthogonal to "don't make user input interface that sucks")
- notalaser 10y agoOr use the same bloody interfaces that have worked for twenty years with the same bloody buttons that have worked for almost a century.
- 72deluxe 10y agoTaking this to a logical conclusion, does this mean we would need to press every key on the physical keyboard twice in case we pressed a key by mistake? It doesn't seem a great thought process or conclusion. I am sure you would agree that if a user interface doesn't respond correctly first time, it isn't a good user interface. Or if the interface makes it possible to do incorrect things with ease or by accident, it's not a great interface either.