3 ms·
I've been thinking about this subject of "cooperation" for the last couple of days (also thanks in part to some links which made it to the front page of HN), an
by paganel 10y ago
I've been thinking about this subject of "cooperation" for the last couple of days (also thanks in part to some links which made it to the front page of HN), and I have something to say about this:
> Eventually this causes the exhaustion of the good, a situation which is bad for everybody. (...) where jokers outbeat defectors and cooperators outperform jokers, which are subsequently invaded by defectors. Thus, paradoxically, the existence of destructive agents acting indiscriminately promotes cooperation."
I'd day that this culture of cooperation for defeating "jokers "doesn't apply to all cultures. It certainly doesn't apply to mine (somewhere in SE-Europe, on the fringe of the Balkans), where a realistic similar scenario would look somth like this:
> Joker does his bad stuff, he shares some of his spoils with his relatives and very close acquaintances (god-fathers, god-sons etc.). These latter people are also part of the community that supposedly should cooperate in annihilating the Joker. Is fair to say that they won't. You've now got a fractured community, with some of its members (the Joker's friends and relatives) having no interest in "cooperation", and more importantly having the economical and power-related means of silencing the part of the community that would want to seek justice (because when you do bad stuff you usually do it in order to increase your economical and power-standing among your community). The Joker becomes an example for other people who see that doing nasty stuff supposedly pays off if you've got enough people by your side. Rinse and repeat.
Aaron Swartz's theory is easier to implement where the Joker is an external element of the community, think immigrants, Jews in early 20-th century Europe, Armenians in late-Ottoman times etc, and I'd say that he's right, those communities actually got a lot more cohesive in chasing out the foreign Joker-like actor(s).
- nostrademons 10y agoI think the point of the "Joker" archetype (as opposed to the "defector" archetype) is that the Joker's actions are purely malicious, not self-interested. In other words, nobody benefits, not even the Joker. In the movie this includes actions like burning money and blowing up hospitals; in real life, it could include actions like nuclear terrorism, destroying holy sites, genetically engineering plagues for the extinction of humanity, blowing up buildings, wanton destruction of famous landmarks, etc. The idea is that when faced with an enemy whose actions are bad for everyone, all the people who previously had been engaging in conduct that was bad for everyone else but good for themselves will be forced to cooperate, lest the world burn to the ground.
- paganel 10y ago> The idea is that when faced with an enemy whose actions are bad for everyone I think this only happens in works of fiction (movies and the like). In real life even things like "terrorism, destroying holy sites, genetically engineering plagues for the extinction of humanity, blowing up buildings, wanton destruction of famous landmarks" have benefits for some members of those communities (ok, maybe not "nuclear terrorism", which is a big no-no for everybody). The recent acts of terrorism in Western Europe have only managed to increase the fracture between the Muslim part of the community (which has been around these parts of the world for some 3 generations) and the rest of the people.
- hueving 10y agoThe ability to short markets makes it very easy to profit off of mass destruction. Blowing up hospitals and even nuclear terrorism could be profitable with well-placed short positions.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>The recent acts of terrorism in Western Europe have only managed to increase the fracture between the Muslim part of the community (which has been around these parts of the world for some 3 generations) and the rest of the people. Daesh have gone pretty far into the Joker realm, I'd say.
- tangent128 10y agoDaesh profits from the fracture, since it feeds their radicalization efforts.
- antisthenes 10y agoHere's a good example of it happening in real life: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Aurora_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Aurora_shooting