3 ms·
> Why try to fix a system... Because perfect really often is the enemy of the good. If a perfect system isn't practically achievable, in the near term at least
by simonh 10y ago
> Why try to fix a system...
Because perfect really often is the enemy of the good. If a perfect system isn't practically achievable, in the near term at least, is there really no point in making any improvement at all? In any case sometimes the best route to an ideal or near-ideal destinations is one step at a time.
- stretchwithme 10y agoThat's why I suggested a good system, rather than a perfect one. Dozens of countries already use proportional representation.
- simonh 10y agoYes, but there's no appetite for a change of that magnitude in the US today. But if PR is your goal, I think a more representative version of the current system is more likely to lead us to that than an increasingly less representative version of it through persistent creeping gerrymandering.
- stretchwithme 10y agoThere's only so much appetite for change. I wouldn't want to waste it on a marginal improvement that only benefits people with similar perspectives if they live in the same area.
- stretchwithme 10y agoAnd switching to proportional representation would help fix lobbyist control of government, which is a huge problem. Ending gerrymandering just changes who is going to serve the lobbyists.
- stretchwithme 10y agoAnd the appetite for change goes up when there is something worth changing for. Helping a few people in a few districts doesn't do much for most people.