5 ms·
Totally meta comment but I'm kind of tired of "quietly" in headlines to add a surreptitious air to something. Almost as bad as "finally" added to make everythin
by ZeroGravitas 10y ago
Totally meta comment but I'm kind of tired of "quietly" in headlines to add a surreptitious air to something. Almost as bad as "finally" added to make everything seem like it's arrived years too late. Is it simply impossible for people to run a news site without blatantly pushing people's buttons?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sp0rk 10y ago> The company didn’t even officially announce the abandonment of the API. Instead, the notice came in the form of an updated Frequently Asked Questions page outlining the termination, and an email to developers active on the platform. That doesn't seem to qualify as "quietly" to me. What did the author expect -- a full-page ad in the New York Times?
- dx034 10y agoA blog article so that everyone who follows Google's announcement will be informed? Blog articles will also be picked up by many tech pages, so it's effectively the NYT equivalent for tech.
- sametmax 10y agoAn article in their blog, at least, explaining their decision and making an official apology. It's good to let people know about it, but it's unprofessional to not publicly acknowledge it. At the very least it's a matter of respect for your community.
- jamespo 10y agoOfficial apology for retiring a free API?
- jsnathan 10y agoSeems to me that when you intentionally lead people to believe that they can depend on you for something in a way that they wouldn't otherwise have, you create an obligation for yourself to keep that promise. Should be that way, anyway.
- sametmax 10y agoIn the case of Google, it's been building product during the last 10 years by doing the following: - offering a free product; - letting people build stuff with it; - create some sort of business model and profit. Google relies on the community to live. e.g: there would be no android without dev creating app for it, so they provide a system API letting you create something on it. Without that, Android would be an empty shell. It's a win-win situation, but to work it needs respect from both sides. Here, I don't see any kind of respect from Google, just another beta product trashed. They have the right to do it, but as a developer, I have the right to not want my time wasted. Hence, if Google wants its community to thrives, it needs to be nice with the people being part of it.
- robbiemitchell 10y agoWhy do they need to apologize?
- arcticfox 10y agoBecause they wasted people's time building on their platform? A successful API requires trust that it will continue, or there's no point in using it. Erode the trust, erode the power of the API publisher. Having been burned by Google API shutdowns before, I just don't use them any more. Obviously they're under no obligation to maintain APIs, but if they want people to keep using them for whatever reason, maintaining trust is important.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoAnd in this computer age, we have to suspect keeping an API available is just some cloud resource of negligible expense. Shutting them down may feed some Google manager's OCD impulse, but can't be saving any money.
- aiiane 10y agoThere is not just a computing resource cost involved - keeping an API around means continuing to support the quirks of that interface, which means code complexity and maintenance costs, especially when the system the API talked to gets refactored and/or overhauled. Google's internal refactoring strategy frequently relies heavily on a monolithic code repository and the ability to rebuild the world; the more that interfaces are unable to change the harder refactoring becomes.
- asciimike 10y ago+1000 to this. The "API" that developers see is the tip of the iceberg for what actually goes into publicly exposing a service to developers. Yes there's quite a bit of internal maintenance that goes on (as mentioned, lots of things change frequently, though generally people refactoring chunks of code will "upgrade" your code for you, since if they don't they can't submit their changes since you were a good engineer and wrote defensive unit tests to protect your code). Maintaining a public API can also mean having: - Documentation (up to 15 languages) - Sample code/example apps (up to 7 languages) - Support (Stack Overflow, Quora, etc.) - An on-call rotation
- sametmax 10y agoIn that case the "quietly" is important, because the article explains that there was no official shout out of this from Google. They just updated their FAQ. Breaking peoples product is bad enough, but not taking the time to make a clean announcement such as on their official blog seems unprofessional to me. Hence the "quietly".
- SlashmanX 10y ago> They just updated their FAQ FTA: > the notice came in the form of an updated Frequently Asked Questions page outlining the termination, and an email to developers active on the platform. Any developers using the API in their product would've received an email.
- robbiemitchell 10y agoWhat products are breaking because of this? It's possible they do not see any significant use. It's also possible they contacted some developers directly. You are making some assumptions here to reach the conclusion they are acting unprofessionally.
- dragonwriter 10y agoThey emailed everyone using the app and updated the documentation for the API itself, and are notifying anyone using an app that relies on the API through the UI. Seems to cover anyone with an interest in the API more effectively than posting on any of Google's many blogs would.
- adzicg 10y agoI tinkered with the hangouts API a year or so ago, and got an e-mail from Google last week about it being discontinued. So not really 'quietly', they notified people who were using it by e-mail. On a side note, the API was so broken, badly documented and useless that when we evaluated embedding an app into hangouts it just seemed as a half-arsed effort by Google to expose an API, and it was clear that they didn't really want people building apps inside hangouts. which is a shame, it seemed as a nice platform to extend with collab tools. I'm not at all surprised this got pulled.
- towndrunk 10y agoCan we add "epic" to that as well?
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoquietly, finally, game changer, open letter, why I am leaving..., why I am joining..., why I quit... All of these can be banned from HN and I'd be happy.
- sctb 10y agoThank you for pointing that out. A moderator took "quietly" out of this title a little while ago.