2 ms·
I don't get it. Of course the economy is non-deterministic. That doesn't mean that useful forecasts can't be made. Statistical models are used because of this.
by nl 10y ago
I don't get it.
Of course the economy is non-deterministic. That doesn't mean that useful forecasts can't be made. Statistical models are used because of this.
I agree of course that deriving and presenting a single forecast from a statistical model is a dangerous process. Perhaps this was the link the author was portraying by their quest for an Isobar map rather than just "Rain/Non rain".
(Also, I see others are looking at "economic forecasting" as price forecasting. I read this more as macro-economic forecasting, in which the outcomes are much to manipulate)
- neximo64 10y agoThe problem is you can make forecasts but they're just guesses at best. The basic model for forecasts for example underestimates the occurrence of black swan events, plain and simple. That's why these days they use the stress test approach, assume the worst market conditions then see if a bank can cope.
- nl 10y agoThe problem is you can make forecasts but they're just guesses at best. This isn't true. The current US unemployment rate is 4.7%[1]. It's pretty easy to look at the time series data, and come up with a likely range for the next reading. The possibility of black swan events (as well as inadequacies of models, measurement inaccuracies etc) mean this number isn't a sure thing: instead a statistical model provides a distribution of probabilities. For example, the probability distribution curve might give an 90% chance of the unemployment rate being between 4.5% and 4.9%. If we are trying to predict a year ahead, there much less certainty. Black swan events are just one of the causes of that, but it's still possible to forecast that the unemployment rate in December 2017 has a (say) 30% chance of being between 5.5% and 4.5%. This isn't guesses (well to be clear: I'm guessing above). You model the inputs, and build a Bayesian belief network (say) to model the interactions between events. Here's a version of The Fed's model: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/notes/feds-notes/2014/a-tool-for-macroeconomic-policy-analysis.html https://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/notes/feds-notes/.... That's why these days they use the stress test approach, assume the worst market conditions then see if a bank can cope. That's completely different to macro-economic forecasting. [1] https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS14000000 https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS14000000
- matt4077 10y agoOh, I agree that it doesn't make much sense. Especially considering that weather forecasting is basically the index case for "hard to predict", i. e. chaos theory. I actually did an analysis of GDP growth forecast for my thesis. If I remember correctly, only the forecasts made in October or later (for that year!) were better than just using the long-term averages – all across central banks and renown research institutions. (Although I should add that the blanket dismissal of economics many draw from such examples may also be a bit to simplistic. It seems like we do have a much better set of tools these days than we had a hundred years ago and even if a crisis hits, we may be better at controlling it before people are starving or starting wars)
- nl 10y agoAre you the author?