5 ms·
Ask HN: With Windows 10's Linux-like feats, do we need native Linux anymore?
- simonebrunozzi 10y agoThis is from the point of view of usability, hardware support, etc - a purely technical angle. I am not interested in philosophical implications (in this thread). Of course, I don't want to prevent you from commenting on this aspect, too, if you still feel this is the right place.
- viraptor 10y agoHow did you even get to that question? In the first sentence, you're assuming that Linux is inferior regarding usability, hardware support, etc. That in its own can be heavily disputed. How about - with recent versions of Wine, do we even need Windows anymore? (Most arguments will apply to both questions)
- mindcrime 10y agoI guess it depends on what you're trying to accomplish. From my perspective, the question is, why do we need native Windows? Personally, I haven't needed Windows for anything since about 2000. Linux has been sufficient for me for the past 17 years. I dunno... if you must run Windows for some reason, then having some linux-like features is nice I guess. Certainly it would be nice to have a proper shell. But why would you run Windows on a server or anything other than maybe a gaming rig, if you play games that only run on Windows?
- savethefuture 10y agoI fixed the typo in your question: "With Linux, do we really need windows anymore?"
- blisterpeanuts 10y agoLong time OpenSuSE, Debian, and Ubuntu user since '98 or so, but I still have two use cases for which Windows is the only choice: 1. Toshiba portable document scanner - works beautifully in Windows, less nicely in MacOS, doesn't work at all in Linux 2. RFID tag programmer - I need it for my work and the only stack that currently exists is the Eclipse JCOP debugger running in Windows. It's orphaned software. I wish wish wish I had a Linux (or even MacOS) driver. 3. Outlook Mail - for work. It runs on a Dell laptop stored on a bookshelf that I occasionally access using VNC. Otherwise would have zero use for that brick. When equipped with LibreOffice, Eclipse, Android Studio, x11vnc, Emacs, VirtualBox, Audacity, Gimp, and a few other niceties, Linux is virtually unstoppable. I'm having trouble thinking of things that Windows 10 can provide that Linux doesn't already have in a lighter weight, easier to configure form. Perhaps others can chime in here?
- DrScump 10y agoDo you then use 2 devices, 1 with dual-boot, or 1 with VM running the alternate OS within VM?
- blisterpeanuts 10y agoseveral devices: MacOS, Linux, and an Intel NUC running Win7. Easier to just have dedicated hardware for each OS for my purposes.
- viraptor 10y agoFortunately 1 and 2 can be solved by throwing money at it. There are portable scanners and RFID programmers which do work on Linux. Re outlook - why not run it in a VM if you only access it periodically anyway?
- makecheck 10y agoI look at it more from a “what’s right” point of view. There is nothing “right” about rewarding Microsoft for offering Linux compatibility in Windows. Microsoft has billions of dollars that it could have invested into its own infrastructure all this time. Instead, they delivered essentially nothing: for YEARS, it has been a pain in the ass to transform any Windows installation into a barely-useful development machine. Oh, and even if you managed to do it, you still had to hope that you wouldn’t encounter some OS-ruining problem that required a full reinstall in 5 months. Instead of creating decent software all these years and building real value, now Microsoft is trying to shoehorn free software such as "bash" into Windows and calling it a feature. To hell with them: not good enough, damn it! Anyone who has been waiting for "bash" on Windows should have been investing in free software projects instead, sending the money where it deserved to go. Think about this: if you’ve given less than $100 to open software projects over the past decade and you’re planning to hand EVEN MORE MONEY to Microsoft over "bash", then you are rewarding the wrong people.