3 ms·
Shouldn't the goal then be to create an environment where white and Asian men are not more qualified? Through education, etc as opposed to giving a job to someo
by pc86 10y ago
Shouldn't the goal then be to create an environment where white and Asian men are not more qualified? Through education, etc as opposed to giving a job to someone less qualified because another applicant because they happen to check different boxes on the Census.
- RodericDay 10y agoDepends. It's been shown that one of the most effective ways of creating an environment is by offering role models. The real purpose of affirmative action is not to benefit a minority at the expense of a non-minority, those are just side-effects. It's to create role models for kids 15-30 years down the line.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- falloutx 10y agoYeah that kind of my point is. If you're giving a job to someone(at the expense of someone more qualified) because of his/her/their race/ethnicity, thats special treatment.
- st3v3r 10y agoYou've just shown your bias by assuming the less represented candidates are less qualified.
- Kluny 10y agoMore women and people of color will pursue the necessary education under their own power when it becomes obvious that they can get jobs with it without having to worry about unemployment due to discrimination. At the moment computer science is often considered a bad bet for women (for example) because they see so few women in the industry that they know it will be an uphill battle to pay off their very expensive degree.
- dotnetisnotdead 10y agoYou are somewhat correct, as it applies to me. I didn't wait for magical liberal policies to fix everything. I pursued this path knowing I was at a disadvantage so I became so good at what I do they can't possibly ignore me. It worked.
- pc86 10y agoSo "give less qualified people jobs because of arbitrary characteristics and people who look like them will become qualified" rather than "hire the most qualified person regardless of any arbitrary characteristics, and people will try to be the most qualified." > At the moment computer science is often considered a bad bet for women (for example) because they see so few women in the industry that they know it will be an uphill battle to pay off their very expensive degree. Nonsense. Things like your comment show that as long as you can pass the bar of "not unqualified" you're more likely to get a job if you're a woman, or a person of color, or whatever random immutable attribute someone is trying to pump up. I work with a bunch of white and Indian dudes. I'd love for the pool of my colleagues to be more diverse. But I'd rather work with 100% qualified Indian men than a group of less qualified people who perfectly match the gender and racial makeup of the US.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoSadly, so often 'qualified' is a subjective thing. And folks just love to imagine that people who are just like themselves seem more qualified. So we get cliques. And its hard to break into one. Also, no need for the strawman of "perfectly match". We could all start with making the effort to find actual, qualified people who help diversify. They're out there.