6 ms·
I think the reason you have those kinds of holy wars among users of a particular technology, whether it's an OS or a gaming console or a programming language, i
by empath75 10y ago
I think the reason you have those kinds of holy wars among users of a particular technology, whether it's an OS or a gaming console or a programming language, is network effects.
All of those things are more valuable the more people that use them, and if you've invested money or time into any of them, you have more of a pay off on your investment if more people also use them. So you might feel strongly incentivized to defend your platform of choice while attacking competing platforms, even if another platform might be marginally better, but not enough to justify the switching costs.
If you're a language developer, you have dual incentives-- one is to get people to use your language, which would seem to encourage you to engage in holy wars, but the other is to be good at developing languages which requires you to think objectively about what you and other language developers are doing, so even if you're publicly defending your choices, you should be open to the idea that another way might be better.
- wrs 10y agoI doubt the vast majority of this behavior is at such a strategic or even conscious level. People are just inherently very tribal, and prone to retroactively rationalizing their choices. That's true in every domain, including programming tools.
- nine_k 10y agoBeing tribal just aligns well with the platform incentive: the more people use it, the better is return on investment for every participant. The participants are not required to be conscious about this; the evolution will favor them anyway if they are really numerous.
- gumby 10y ago> I think the reason you have those kinds of holy wars among users of a particular technology...is network effects. I find the holy wars are usually fueled by "fans" -- people less invested and less knowledgable in the topic. This is true of movies, bands, sports teams, phones, computers and cars. The fact is if you work on the tech you appreciate that there are tradeoffs and know what your overall objective is (so are less likely to argue about things that don't get you there). Musicians tend to get along -- did the Beatles hate the Stones (OK, the Stones released "Let it Bleed"). I doubt Mark Hamill hates Star Trek or Shatner Star Wars. The catholic pope meets with the grand mufti of Jarusalem. Obama and Bush talked a lot in 2008 and 2009. It's like the joke about academia being so cutthroat as the stakes are so small. Holy / Flame wars erupt among those on the periphery at best.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> I find the holy wars are usually fueled by "fans" -- people less invested and less knowledgable in the topic. There seems, IME, to be a sizable contingent of people who have invested heavily in a particular technology and are threatened, in their own market value, by threats to its distribution, in most technology flamewars. They aren't necessarily less knowledgeable, but frequently prefer depth in a platform to breadth across platforms for developing their own skill set, which creates a strong incentive to promote the platform.
- ISL 10y agoIt took me a long time to understand the 'stakes are so small' statement about academia. I used to see it as a humorous statement about the disconnected irrelevance of academia. As a professional academic, I now read it as 'the stakes are so few'. Academic politics are rigidly contained by existing structures and limited funding. There may only be one or two ways to 'win' within the framework, with a limited number of 'winners'. In such an environment, vicious politics may be unsurprising.
- stcredzero 10y agoReminds me of what a touring musician friend of mine said about the Austin trad music scene. "It's cute how they bicker so much. You'd think real money was involved!"
- guelo 10y agoI think there's more to it than that. Languages, including programming languages, affect the way you think. When you're proficient in a language your brain adjusts to the language's styles and limitations so you can express yourself efficiently using those modes of thought. If you are only proficient in one language you can fall into the trap of thinking it is the only way of expressing your thoughts efficiently, and that's where you get the heated flame wars. This is why it is important to become proficient in languages with completely different paradigms to better understand the trade-offs. When I switch between two languages in which I am proficient I can almost feel my brain shifting gears to a different mode of thought.
- grey-area 10y agoWittgenstein put this really well : The language that I speak defines the limits of my world. I've always thought it was particularly apt for programming languages.
- PeCaN 10y agoI find it a bit funny that the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, though invented for and now largely discredited for natural languages, turns out to strongly apply to programming languages. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity
- guelo 10y agoWikipedia says "Currently, a balanced view of linguistic relativity is espoused by most linguists", so I wouldn't call it discredited, just more nuanced.
- jcranmer 10y agoPeople have used the term linguistic relativity to mean anything on a vast range of specific hypotheses, which makes it hard to figure out what exactly people mean when they say it's been proven or disproven. Nevertheless, it's pretty clear to most people that the stronger forms of the hypothesis--the idea that language is essentially a straightjacket on the kinds of thoughts you can express (or linguistic determination in general)--is thoroughly debunked. I personally rather suspect that the weaker forms (that language generally shapes but not fully limits how you view the world) are also equally fallacious, even if language and world-views might be weakly correlative--instead, I see language and world-view as essentially both being strongly derived from that of those who teach you.