3 ms·
Isn't libertarian thinking (put very heavily on the edge) the exact opposite? That a system will become more efficient if actors are let to do things for their
by wodenokoto 10y ago
Isn't libertarian thinking (put very heavily on the edge) the exact opposite?
That a system will become more efficient if actors are let to do things for their own sake, and that actors are smart enough to calculate the negative impact of short term selfish action (that is, actors can help out now, with an exception of a positive roi)
- SonOfLilit 10y agoThis assumes a theoretical optimal central planner, a superintelligent BDFL of sorts. Libertarian thinking is that in practice humans are so bad at management that every time we tried central planning it came up even worse than non-optimal Nash Equilibria (which are the failure mode of non-centrally-managed agent systems.) Libertarians would say that no dictator or government in history turned out to know better than The Market. That The Cost of Regulation is higher than The Cost of Anarchy. Of course, both costs are high for some problems and low for others, and the solution to practical problems usually lies at neither this extreme nor that one.
- adgasf 10y agoSome Libertarians are non-consequentialists. They argue that even if the outcome is less efficient, there are moral reasons to oppose central planning. What is interesting is that many argue both points: that markets are more efficient and morally superior. A good example of the distinction is David D. Friedman (consequentialist) vs Ayn Rand (non-consequentialist).
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoLibertarian thinking actually permits multiple people to agree to not take the most immediately greedy action and to instead voluntarily agree to a mutually-beneficial optimal solution.