2 ms·
You're talking about the grammatical, but nonsensical sentence "colorless green ideas sleep furiously" proposed by Chomsky, along with its ungrammatical counter
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
You're talking about the grammatical, but nonsensical sentence "colorless
green ideas sleep furiously" proposed by Chomsky, along with its ungrammatical
counterpart, "Furiously sleep ideas green colorless." [1] Chomsky famously
said that one of the two sentences is ungrammatical, but both would be assigned a low
probability by a statistical model trained on English corpora. The
one who showed that the ungrammatical sentence was (much) less likely than
the grammatical one was Fernando Pereira, not Peter Norvig. Peter Norvig has
argued against Chomsky in a different instance, and cited Pereira during that
(one-sided) exchange, if memory serves.
This is completely unrelated to what I'm saying, of course. The fact of the
matter is that you can't just swap some words out of a sentence and call it
"ungrammatical". You can call it a "perturbed" sentence. You can call it a
"sentence with some words dropped". You can call it Daisy Duck for all I care.
But it's not an ungrammatical sentence, because that sort of thing has a very
precise definition, which I gave above.
_______________
[1] The sentence is famous enough to have a wikipedia page all its own:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorless_green_ideas_sleep_furiously https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorless_green_ideas_sleep_fu...