2 ms·
> giant attempt to redefine things until you are right. That would be the no true scotsman I guess, but actually you invoked this with your "crazy" feminism. I
by Chris2048 10y ago
> giant attempt to redefine things until you are right.
That would be the no true scotsman I guess, but actually you invoked this with your "crazy" feminism. I'm the one that said there isn't really any such thing as a singular feminism.
> Not to mention the circular logic
No, the circular logic is in your poor interpretation.
> which is bad because feminism is bad.
This is a consistent argument, about which I say more. It's only circular in the strict way you stated it, which is a purposeful misrepresentation in order to portray it as circular.
> ignoring the actual points I made
which are the important ones I ignored? You say a lot that doesn't follow strictly from the points I made, and don't expand on them. If I responded to everything you write I'd be doing a lot of the work; for example, you throw out a load of ungrounded accusations, which I generally ignore.
> made a post saying the site was bad because it is portraying feminism incorrectly
> Stay on topic to the core point.
If you want the thread to stay on topic, then stay on topic yourself. I've generally just responded.
> You argue that the article/site are reasonable, because feminism is now largely an extremist movement now, and it is anti-men enough to be a problem, not simply pro-women.
Some feminism. And if you can't see the distinction, then probably your feminism.
> Discrimination against women still happens
This is a low bar. What does it mean? I've stated enough times a need for specific standards for what constitutes "unequal", so what exactly do you mean by this?
> cherry-pick bits to strawman
I can only "cherry-pick to strawman" if I misrepresent your arguments (as a strawman), which did I misrepresent?
- Latty 10y ago> That would be the no true scotsman I guess, but actually you invoked this with your "crazy" feminism. I'm the one that said there isn't really any such thing as a singular feminism. And yet you are willing to say anyone teaching what they call feminism to their child is doing wrong because of it. > This is a consistent argument, about which I say more. It's only circular in the strict way you stated it, which is a purposeful misrepresentation in order to portray it as circular. Then why is feminism bad?
- Chris2048 10y ago> And yet you are No, try reading what I've written (multiple times now). > Then why is feminism bad? certain forms are bad, for whatever makes them bad. At this point, I'm not sure you know the difference between a generalization and an absolute statement.
- Latty 10y agoThen how can you possibly defend that site, which is clearly misrepresenting a feminist with a reasonable viewpoint?
- Chris2048 10y agoIf there's a misrepresentation going on, that's one thing, But that the viewpoint here is 'reasonable' is your opinion, not fact.
- Latty 10y agoAnd if I say 'slavery is wrong' - that's an opinion. I'm going to go ahead and call someone reasonable when they pen an anti-slavery piece. You disagree with me about the viewpoint being reasonable - sure. I think you are horribly wrong. The viewpoint makes sense, and I have explained why I think that. She is explaining her struggle in dealing with explaining feminism and dealing with sexism to her future son, given she was never a young boy and doesn't know it. You haven't explained how you got to that being unreasonable except implying (but then denying) you think feminism is inherently bad.