2 ms·
> Yes, it is If you say so... > No, but it's a good place to start. Not really. A search engine brings you what you are looking for, and can be easily biased
by Chris2048 10y ago
> Yes, it is
If you say so...
> No, but it's a good place to start.
Not really. A search engine brings you what you are looking for, and can be easily biased by many factors, including the popularity and phrasing implications of a question
> Things like [this]
This study applies to one context. Many studies only apply to many contexts. You need at least one study applying to the universal context, i.e on a random selection of the population, to prove it of society in general.
More hand waving "lot of studies" - are these studies representative? Many studies are performed in certain areas because there is a previous suspicion of bias there. Many studies focus on gender due to the popularity of the subject, when in fact the biases exist due to correlations with other factors (wealth, education, etc) or the narrow focus of the study (high earners, but not low earners); so even studies that show sexual "bias" needn't imply unfairness or sexism if either the relevant factor isn't sex (just something that correlates), or if the underlying cause isn't unfair (by some definition).
Incidentally, social science, and in particular the field of psychology, have had issue reproducing results, e.g http://www.pnas.org/content/112/17/5360.full.pdf http://www.pnas.org/content/112/17/5360.full.pdf
> they have so little influence that is rare
> You are characterising normal reasonable people under the crazy banner.
Given what you consider reasonable, this maybe begs the question. I think maybe your "crazy" is a straw feminist that you have already counted yourself as not being one.
> Show me the articles
Any article covering the wage gap with the implication that "something must be done"
> It's not a commonplace thing or a big problem
Not to feminists, no.
> you have a problem with it?
Yes, it assumes what that influence is without evidence
>> I'm not sure it's all feminism at all.
>It is
Well, here's hoping for an enlightened fourth-wave then. That said, #notallwomen #notyourshield
> You have constructed..
whatever you say, doc
- Latty 10y agoAh yes, the good old "studies can be wrong" and moving the goal-posts to require impossible to perform studies. It's not possible to show something like sexism universally because what is the indicator everyone does you test? You call it hand-waving, but you are the one hand-waving away the evidence we have that sexism exists. You focus on the wage gap, but that's just one argument people make - and just because some people interpret the data wrongly (expecting 1:1 to be the right outcome, disregarding the difference in common career paths), that doesn't make it entirely wrong (sexism could still be a factor - it's hard to tell), and it doesn't make it malicious or the whole of feminism somehow invalid. I see plenty of discussion about that, and I don't see people trying to force through 1:1 as the standard. Yes, amazingly there are people who call themselves feminists and are wrong, like with anything. If we had a site that was citing the wage gap, demanding 1:1 pay regardless of situation, etc... I would be onboard with calling it wrong. That doesn't magically make a site tarnishing feminists with legitimate arguments and aims as wrong. That article was reasonable unless you think teaching a child about feminism is wrong, which implies that feminism is inherantly wrong, not just potentially in the wrong hands.
- Chris2048 10y agoAh, the good old "the good old". Diagnosing everything I say as some classic fallacy only works if you can explain why it's wrong. Did I not post a contradicting study? http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/12/beware-the-man-of-one-study/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/12/beware-the-man-of-one-s... Again, please expand; where did I move the goalpost? > It's not possible to show something like sexism universally It might be, it'd just be hard. I assume from the above you are accepting I was right? > but you are the one hand-waving away the evidence we have that sexism exists This isn't what 'hand waving' in the former context means. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand-waving https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand-waving The burden is on you to provide evidence for your overly general statements. > that's just one argument people make I picked that as a good example. Do you have a better one? > that doesn't make it entirely wrong It doesn't make what wrong? The wage gap? ok - but I never claimed it was - there is no evidence it is a problem, and by default we don't act on things that are not wrong. Sexism can, and to some degree will, be a factor; The question is what can be shown by reasonable analysis, as opposed to ideological rhetoric. I think you are the one moving the goalposts here. You appear to have gone from "sexism definitely exists, we are all a little sexist" to "we don't know sexism doesn't exist". > or the whole of feminism somehow invalid Please stick to the things I said. This is the second time I'm saying this now. you are the one making generalizations here. > I don't see people trying to force through 1:1 as the standard Yet, it's the wage gap "problem" than inspires things like https://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/mar/06/germany-gender-quota-legislation-boardroom-law-women https://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/mar/06/germany-gen... > unless you think teaching a child about feminism is wrong I'm going to stop arguing this because I think you are being willfully ignorant. I clearly don't thing "teaching a child about feminism" is the correct characterisation, nor accept your "implication" (I've said twice now I believe the feminism shown here not to be "all" feminism) so repeatedly trying to frame it like this is not productive.
- Latty 10y agoYou are simply changing your argument every time to avoid having to answer why you are defending the site which has clearly misleading articles. If you don't think teaching children about feminism is wrong, and you don't think all feminism is bad, how can you possibly defend that? I'm simply trying to make your argument make sense, not putting words in your mouth. You are denying everything while making the assertion I'm wrong to say that site is attempting to create a fear of feminism. You are refusing to explain why you think their content is reasonable, I'm trying to work out why that is.